March 2024

Explore

3/12 - Creative Dialogue - The ECHO Way and Creative Life

今天晚上，看到 Raghav Agrawal 的推文，于是设计了一下Creative Dialogue的图片。

⁠

⁠

前一阵子做CALL的新版本网站时，就想要把 creative dialogue这个部分的案例整理一下。这次可以作为三月份的创作成果。

Raghav Agrawal I think the key to synthesizing anything is to create a dialogue between those things, to facilitate interactions. To let the unique qualities of each be extended, amplified and moulded via dialogues. In that regard I think Bakhtin was onto something...

⁠

https://twitter.com/impactology/status/1767556670933385408⁠

⁠

Which profession's day to day work involves blending concepts by questioning the delineation of meaning of words, their associations and relationships?

⁠

https://twitter.com/impactology/status/1767540108360827158⁠

⁠

..with his concept of Heteroglossia and Dialogism

https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/in-theory-bakhtin-1/⁠

⁠

Bakhtin: Dialogism, Polyphony and Heteroglossia

In the latest addition to his A-Z of Theory series, political theorist Andrew Robinson introduces, in a two-part essay, the work of Mikhail Bakhtin, one of the most important theorists of discourse in the twentieth century. In part one, Robinson introduces Bakhtin's notions of Dialogism, Polyphony and Heteroglossia.

⁠

https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/in-theory-bakhtin-1/⁠

⁠

Bakhtin: Carnival against Capital, Carnival against Power

In the second and final part of his essay on Mikhail Bakhtin, political theorist Andrew Robinson reviews, and critiques, one of the central concepts in the Russian thinker's work: the Carnivalesque.

⁠

https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/in-theory-bakhtin-2/⁠

⁠

使用这个旧图片的文章：

Creative Journey: The ECHO Way to Creative Work Study (Note) Oct 1, 2022

https://medium.com/call4/creative-journey-ef5008dfc834⁠

⁠

原始图片：

⁠

https://unsplash.com/photos/high-angle-photo-of-two-green-mugs-filled-with-coffee-c2Y16tC3yO8⁠

⁠

3/19/2024 - DEEP

D as Diagramming: The DEEP Framework

July 18, 2021

⁠

https://medium.com/call4/deep-5df0bb046341⁠

⁠

There are many mental moves that appear in my one-year journey of engaging with Lui’s theoretical sociology. I’d like to claim that this is a Supportive Collaboration.

Moreover, we can use
the DEEP framework⁠
to understand Supportive Collaboration. See the diagram below.

Self: Curativity Center (Oliver Ding)

Social Environment: The Trojan Society for Theoretical Sociology (Ping-keung Lui)

The above diagram is based on the ECHO Way model. The basis of the diagram is using three containers to explore possible connections.

Container X: Self, a person wants to actualize a Possible Self with a Developmental Project.

Container Y: Social Environment, a platform that wants to actualize a Possible Practice with projects initiated by its members.

⁠
https://medium.com/the-art-of-bagging/engaging-with-luis-theoretical-sociology-81afd3ff5114⁠
⁠

⁠

3/25/2204 - Creative Dialogue model

CALL网站上有这个网页

https://www.callfordive.com/en/dialogue⁠

⁠

另外，我昨天看到

Value Circle #7: The Indirect Activity of Life Strategy Center⁠

文章中提到的这个对话，也应该放到这个书稿中。

⁠

因此，Creative Dialogue 不是简单的三容器模型的重复应用案例，而是Creative Life Theory的一个新的分析单元和概念。

反过来说更为合适，Creative Dialogue 这个分析单元，可以容纳很多的具体的框架和模型，三容器模型仅仅是其中之一。

Creative Life Theory > Creative Dialogue > The ECHO Way + Two Thematic Spaces + Slow Talks> Applications

Applications:

Two people

Two knowledge centers

Two approaches

Two themes

Slow Talks 也可以收录到这个文集中。

⁠

https://medium.com/tale500/thematic-exploration-f5822dcbf0d8⁠

⁠

书稿概括

Part 1 Introduction

Part 2 The ECHO Way

Part 3 Slow Talks

Part 4 Double Themes

Creative Life Theory 书稿第7章的内容如下：

Chapter 7: Creative Dialogue

Part 1:

The ECHO Way (v2.0)⁠

(15 min)

Part 2:

Theme U for Single-theory Curation⁠

(23 min)

Part 3:

WXMY for Interdisciplinary Curation⁠

(25 min)

Part 4:

Personal Innovation as Career-fit⁠

(22 min)

Part 5:

The “Activity — Opportunity” Thematic Dialogue⁠

(19 min)

Part 6:

The Echoes of A Thematic Dialogue⁠

(13 min)

Part 7: The “Project — Platform” Creative Dialogue (

Mental Moves #2: Creative Swapping of Mental Elements⁠

) (19 min)

Part 8: The “Theoretical Sociology — Creative Life Theory” Creative Dialogue (

Mental Moves #4: Attachance and Creative Dialogue⁠

) (14 min)

⁠

Knowledge Circle: 创意对话是知识中心的关键活动

3/25/2024 晚上想到，吕老师的理论社会学的对话分析，也应该放到这里。

3/16/2024

今天上午检索这个信息，发现，我是用了knowledge circle这个框架，它是派生自 activity circle这个基础框架。

Knowledge Engagement: The Expanded Creative Course Framework

⁠

https://medium.com/the-art-of-bagging/expanded-creative-course-31a2378a79f⁠

因此，这里构成了一个模式：

应用背景：知识中心

元图示或基础框架：activit circle

情境框架：knowledge circle

这似乎就是一个主题三角啊。

看起来，这次要用【主题三角】的构思来整理这一系列案例。

⁠

3/26/2024 - Joint Knowledge Center and Value Circle

今天上午继续思考这个设想，我回顾关于主题空间的讨论以及知识中心的讨论，看来，knowledge circle只是处于知识中心内部的讨论框架，我们还可以探讨知识中心外部，以及知识中心之间的情况。

如此一来，这个层次感就比较明显了。

一个人 (学派 - 学派)

单一的知识中心(二个人)

合作的知识中心(二个人)

价值圈(知识中心 - 知识中心)

主题对话，这个仅仅是考虑两个人，没有考虑 [知识中心] 这个背景，那么，它们的背景是什么呢？

我和东兴的讨论，当时作为一个主题区的案例。

⁠

3/26/2024

The ECHO Way : Robert Kegan’s case study: the theme of “Mental Complexity”

参考如下图形：

⁠

The ECHO Way - Robert Kegan - - Mental Complexity - March 26, 2024.png

⁠

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.