Skip to content
Car Model Reviews
Updated_Car_Comparison_with_Tesla_Model_Y__Recreated_
Vehicle
Safety Features
Safety Features Explanation
Comfort and Convenience
Comfort and Convenience Explanation
Technology
Technology Explanation
Performance
Performance Explanation
Fuel Efficiency
Fuel Efficiency Explanation
Interior Space
Interior Space Explanation
Cargo Space
Cargo Space Explanation
Advanced Driver Assistance
Advanced Driver Assistance Explanation
Final Letter Grade
Final Verdict Explanation
Estimated Purchase Price
Purchase Price Explanation
Fuel Cost (10 years)
Fuel Cost Explanation
Maintenance (10 years)
Maintenance Explanation
Resale Value After 10 Years
Resale Value Explanation
Setup Cost
Misc Costs Explanation
Total 10 Year Cost
Total Cost Explanation
1
Volkswagen ID.4
A
Summary: Excellent safety features with advanced driver assistance.
Forward Collision Warning with Autonomous Emergency Braking: Alerts the driver to potential collisions and automatically applies the brakes if needed.
Blind Spot Monitor with Rear Traffic Alert: Warns the driver of vehicles in the blind spot and approaching traffic when reversing.
B+
Summary: Modern interior with comfortable features, though not as luxurious as some.
Spacious Interior: Provides a roomy cabin with modern, minimalist design and comfortable seating for long trips.
Dual-Zone Climate Control: Allows personalized temperature settings for driver and front passenger.
Touchscreen Controls: The large infotainment screen integrates most vehicle controls, enhancing convenience but requiring familiarity with digital interfaces.
A-
Summary: Advanced tech with a focus on EV-specific features and connectivity.
10 or 12-Inch Touchscreen: Includes navigation, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto for seamless smartphone integration.
Over-the-Air Software Updates: Keeps the vehicle’s software up to date without requiring a visit to the dealership.
ID.Light System: An innovative light strip that visually communicates driving information, such as charge status and navigation cues.
B+
Summary: EV torque provides quick acceleration and a smooth ride.
A
Summary: All-electric driving offers unmatched fuel efficiency.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 104 MPGe (combined city/highway).
B+
Summary: Decent space for an EV, though less than traditional SUVs.
B
Summary: Cargo space is decent, though less than traditional gas-powered SUVs.
Cargo Capacity: 30.3 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 64.2 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
A
Summary: Advanced safety features and driver assistance tech as standard.
Specific Feature: Travel Assist allows for semi-autonomous driving with adaptive cruise control and lane-centering technology.
A-
Summary: The ID.4 excels in efficiency, tech, and long-term costs, making it a great option for those looking to transition to EVs.
Offers lower fuel and maintenance costs compared to gas and hybrid options, making it budget-friendly in the long run.
Advanced technology, including over-the-air updates and EV-specific features, keeps it modern and future-proof.
The standard driver assistance suite provides comprehensive safety, making it a secure choice for EV adopters.
$25,000.00
Affordable for an EV with modern features.
$5,000.00
Electricity is cheaper than gas, with significant savings over time.
$4,000.00
Lower maintenance due to fewer moving parts in EVs.
$8,000.00
EVs tend to depreciate faster but still retain some value.
$2,000.00
Not eligible for Used EV Tax Credit
$7500 tax credit for new EV car
Installing Level 2 home charging: $1,000 to $2,500
Estimated JEA Rebate: $200 to $500
$28,000.00
Significant long-term savings due to low fuel and maintenance costs.
2
Honda CR-V (Gas)
A
Summary: High safety ratings with reliable safety technology.
Collision Mitigation Braking System (CMBS): Automatically applies brakes to reduce the severity of a collision.
Road Departure Mitigation System: Helps prevent unintentional lane departures by applying gentle steering corrections.
B
Summary: Functional and comfortable, but lacks some high-end features.
Spacious Cabin: Offers excellent headroom and legroom for both front and rear passengers.
Heated Front Seats: Provides extra comfort during colder months.
Easy Fold-Down 60/40 Rear Seats: Makes expanding cargo space quick and convenient, adding versatility.
B
Summary: Standard technology features but lacks some advanced options.
7-Inch Touchscreen Display: Integrates Apple CarPlay and Android Auto for easy connectivity.
Multi-Angle Rearview Camera: Provides multiple camera views when reversing for enhanced safety.
Available Satellite-Linked Navigation: Provides turn-by-turn directions, available in higher trims.
B
Summary: Reliable performance but nothing extraordinary.
C
Summary: Gas-powered models have higher fuel costs.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 28 MPG (combined city/highway).
A
Summary: Spacious interior with plenty of room for passengers and cargo.
A
Summary: Lots of cargo space, one of the CR-V's strong points.
Cargo Capacity: 39.2 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 75.8 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
B+
Summary: Strong safety tech but lacking some advanced features.
Specific Feature: Honda Sensing Suite includes adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, and collision mitigation braking as standard.
B+
Summary: The CR-V (Gas) is a solid, reliable choice with good resale value, but higher long-term costs.
Known for its spacious interior and practical design, it’s a great all-purpose SUV.
Reliability and strong resale value make it a dependable investment, though higher fuel costs add up over time.
Lacks the fuel efficiency of hybrids and EVs, making it a less economical choice for long-term ownership.
$24,000.00
A solid choice for a reliable SUV.
$15,000.00
Gasoline costs add up, especially for frequent drivers.
$6,000.00
Standard maintenance costs for a reliable gas engine.
$10,000.00
Holds value well, reflecting Honda's reliability reputation.
$35,000.00
Higher fuel and maintenance costs lead to higher long-term expenses.
3
Honda CR-V Hybrid
A
Summary: Top safety ratings and hybrid technology ensure security.
Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC): Maintains a safe distance from the car ahead by automatically adjusting speed.
Lane Keeping Assist System (LKAS): Provides gentle steering to help keep the vehicle centered in its lane.
B+
Summary: Hybrid adds a touch of comfort and efficiency.
Dual-Zone Automatic Climate Control: Enables both driver and passenger to set individual temperature preferences.
Heated Front Seats: Adds comfort in cold weather, enhancing the driving experience.
Power Tailgate: Allows easy access to the rear cargo area with a hands-free function on higher trims.
B+
Summary: Hybrid tech adds a layer of modern efficiency and functionality.
HondaLink App Integration: Allows remote access to the vehicle, including locking/unlocking and finding your car.
7-Inch Display Audio System: Features Apple CarPlay and Android Auto as standard for smartphone integration.
Available Wireless Phone Charging: Adds convenience by eliminating the need for charging cables in higher trims.
B+
Summary: Hybrid tech enhances efficiency and performance.
A-
Summary: Hybrid tech significantly improves fuel efficiency.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 38 MPG (combined city/highway).
A
Summary: Hybrid maintains the spacious interior of the CR-V.
A
Summary: Hybrid maintains strong cargo space without sacrificing room.
Cargo Capacity: 33.2 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 68.7 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
A-
Summary: Hybrid models come with upgraded driver assistance.
Specific Feature: Traffic Sign Recognition displays road signs on the driver display for increased situational awareness.
B+
Summary: The CR-V Hybrid balances efficiency and comfort, with strong resale value and reasonable long-term costs.
Provides better fuel efficiency compared to its gas counterpart, saving money on fuel over time.
Retains the CR-V’s spacious interior and practicality, making it versatile for both daily driving and road trips.
Offers a smooth driving experience with seamless transitions between gas and electric power.
$27,000.00
Pricier but with hybrid savings over time.
$11,000.00
Hybrid efficiency reduces fuel costs compared to gas models.
$5,000.00
Slightly lower maintenance with hybrid components.
$11,000.00
Hybrids retain strong resale value with efficiency in mind.
$32,000.00
Hybrid tech reduces costs over time, offering a balanced option.
4
Toyota RAV4 (Gas)
A
Summary: Excellent safety ratings, a hallmark of Toyota.
Pre-Collision System with Pedestrian Detection: Detects potential collisions with vehicles or pedestrians and applies the brakes automatically.
Lane Departure Alert with Steering Assist: Warns the driver if they unintentionally drift out of the lane and provides steering assistance.
B
Summary: Comfortable, with a focus on reliability and practicality.
Spacious Seating: Provides comfortable seating for five passengers with good legroom in both rows.
Dual-Zone Automatic Climate Control: Lets both front passengers set their preferred temperatures.
Optional Power Liftgate: Adds convenience for loading and unloading cargo, especially with hands full.
B
Summary: Standard tech for the class, nothing groundbreaking.
7-Inch or 8-Inch Touchscreen: Includes Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Amazon Alexa compatibility.
Optional JBL Premium Audio System: Provides high-quality sound for music lovers.
Entune 3.0 System: Offers app integration and navigation through the smartphone-linked system.
B
Summary: Solid performance, typical of a gas-powered SUV.
C
Summary: Gas models suffer from higher fuel consumption.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 30 MPG (combined city/highway).
A
Summary: Excellent space, a hallmark of the RAV4.
A
Summary: Class-leading cargo space for the RAV4.
Cargo Capacity: 37.6 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 69.8 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
B+
Summary: Good safety features, but not as advanced as the top-tier.
Specific Feature: Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 includes Lane Tracing Assist, which helps keep the vehicle centered in its lane.
B+
Summary: The RAV4 (Gas) offers reliability and space, but fuel and maintenance costs make it less appealing than hybrid alternatives.
Strong reliability and resale value, but higher fuel and maintenance costs compared to hybrid options.
Offers excellent cargo space and a comfortable ride, making it practical for families and outdoor enthusiasts.
Lacks the fuel efficiency of the RAV4 Hybrid, which is a better choice for long-term savings.
$25,000.00
Affordable with strong resale value.
$15,000.00
Higher fuel costs with traditional gasoline engines.
$6,000.00
Average maintenance costs for a gas-powered SUV.
$11,000.00
Strong resale value due to Toyota's reliability.
$35,000.00
Traditional gas engines lead to higher fuel and maintenance costs.
5
Toyota RAV4 Hybrid
A
Summary: Hybrid tech and safety features offer maximum security.
Dynamic Radar Cruise Control (DRCC): Automatically adjusts speed to maintain a safe following distance on the highway.
Blind Spot Monitor with Rear Cross-Traffic Alert: Alerts the driver to vehicles in the blind spot and traffic approaching from the side when reversing.
B+
Summary: Hybrid adds both comfort and convenience to the RAV4 lineup.
Comfortable Seating with Lumbar Support: Ensures a more ergonomic ride, especially on long trips.
Heated and Ventilated Front Seats: Available in higher trims, offering year-round comfort.
Power Liftgate with Height Adjustment: Provides customizable convenience for easy cargo access.
B+
Summary: Hybrid technology improves the tech appeal.
7-Inch or 8-Inch Touchscreen: Includes Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and available navigation.
Toyota Hybrid System Display: Provides detailed information on hybrid power usage and efficiency.
Available Wireless Charging Pad: Adds convenience for charging compatible smartphones.
B+
Summary: Hybrid powertrain improves performance without sacrificing efficiency.
A-
Summary: Hybrid technology delivers better fuel economy.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 40 MPG (combined city/highway).
A
Summary: Hybrid models maintain the same great space.
A
Summary: Hybrid retains great cargo capacity with added efficiency.
Cargo Capacity: 37.6 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 69.8 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down (same as the gas model).
A-
Summary: Hybrid models include more advanced driver assistance features.
Specific Feature: Dynamic Radar Cruise Control maintains a set distance from vehicles ahead and adjusts speed automatically.
A-
Summary: The RAV4 Hybrid shines with great efficiency, advanced features, and better long-term value.
Excellent fuel efficiency compared to gas models, significantly reducing long-term costs.
Offers a robust set of safety and driver assistance features, making it both safe and reliable.
Retains the same spacious cargo and interior space as the gas version, without sacrificing performance.
$28,000.00
Hybrid technology comes with a slight premium.
$11,000.00
Hybrid tech reduces fuel costs significantly over time.
$5,000.00
Lower maintenance costs thanks to hybrid technology.
$12,000.00
Hybrid technology and Toyota's reputation support resale value.
$32,000.00
Hybrid tech reduces fuel costs, leading to better long-term value.
6
Mazda CX-5 (Gas)
A
Summary: Great safety technology and crash test ratings.
Smart Brake Support: Detects potential collisions and automatically applies the brakes to reduce impact.
Rear Cross-Traffic Alert: Warns the driver of vehicles approaching from the side when reversing.
B
Summary: A stylish interior with decent comfort but not top-tier.
Premium Materials: Features high-quality materials throughout the cabin, giving a luxurious feel even in lower trims.
Heated Front Seats and Steering Wheel: Adds comfort during cold weather.
Power Liftgate: Available in higher trims for easy access to the rear cargo area.
B
Summary: Stylish but not as tech-heavy as some competitors.
10.25-Inch Full-Color Display: Features Mazda Connect infotainment system with navigation and smartphone integration.
Bose 10-Speaker Audio System: Available in higher trims for an enhanced audio experience.
Mazda Connected Services: Provides remote access to vehicle status, remote start, and more via smartphone.ot as tech-heavy as some competitors.
B
Summary: Decent performance, especially in urban settings.
C
Summary: Gas models lack the efficiency of hybrids and EVs.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 26 MPG (combined city/highway).
B
Summary: A bit smaller than competitors but still functional.
B
Summary: Smaller cargo space compared to other models.
Cargo Capacity: 30.9 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 59.6 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
B+
Summary: Good safety tech but could be more advanced.
Specific Feature: Mazda Radar Cruise Control with Stop & Go adjusts speed and can bring the vehicle to a stop in traffic.
B
Summary: The Mazda CX-5 (Gas) is stylish and well-rounded, but higher fuel costs and less space impact its overall grade.
Known for its upscale interior and stylish design, making it stand out in the segment.
Offers great handling and driving dynamics, but smaller cargo space compared to competitors.
Higher fuel costs reduce its overall value in comparison to more efficient rivals like hybrids and EVs.
$24,000.00
Stylish and practical with a lower entry cost.
$15,000.00
Similar fuel costs as other gas SUVs.
$6,000.00
Typical maintenance for a gas-powered vehicle.
$10,000.00
Mazda holds its value relatively well.
$35,000.00
Higher costs due to fuel consumption and maintenance.
7
Mazda CX-5 Hybrid
A
Summary: Hybrid models keep up with safety and tech advancements.
Driver Attention Alert: Monitors driver behavior and provides alerts if signs of drowsiness or inattention are detected.
i-Activsense Safety Suite: Includes features like Lane Departure Warning and Adaptive Cruise Control with Stop & Go functionality.
B+
Summary: Hybrid adds efficiency while keeping comfort in focus.
Refined Interior with Premium Touchpoints: Offers a high-quality, upscale cabin experience across all trims.
Dual-Zone Climate Control: Ensures both the driver and front passenger can adjust the temperature to their liking.
Heated and Ventilated Seats: Available in higher trims, providing comfort for all seasons.
B+
Summary: Hybrid adds modern tech efficiency.
10.25-Inch Infotainment Display: Includes navigation and smartphone integration with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Heads-Up Display (HUD): Projects driving information onto the windshield for easy viewing while driving.
Remote Start and Vehicle Status Monitoring: Available via Mazda Connected Services app, enhancing convenience and control.
B+
Summary: Hybrid adds a performance boost over the gas version.
A-
Summary: Hybrid models improve fuel efficiency.
Fuel Efficiency: Estimated 37 MPG (combined city/highway).
B
Summary: Hybrid doesn't affect space, but it's still smaller than rivals.
B
Summary: Hybrid models retain the same cargo capacity as the gas version.
Cargo Capacity: 30.9 cubic feet behind the rear seats, 59.6 cubic feet with the rear seats folded down.
A-
Summary: Hybrid tech boosts the driver assistance capabilities.
Specific Feature: i-Activsense Safety Suite includes Smart City Brake Support, which automatically applies brakes to avoid collisions at lower speeds.
B+
Summary: The Mazda CX-5 Hybrid adds efficiency, but it still can't quite match the top-tier hybrids in overall value.
Improves fuel efficiency over the gas model, making it a more economical option for those seeking a hybrid.
Retains Mazda’s hallmark stylish design and upscale interior, appealing to those who prioritize aesthetics.
Faces tough competition from other hybrid SUVs that offer more space and better overall long-term value.
$27,000.00
Hybrid adds efficiency but increases upfront cost.
$11,000.00
Hybrid tech reduces fuel expenses.
$5,000.00
Hybrid components reduce long-term maintenance costs.
$11,000.00
Hybrid models retain a bit more value.
$32,000.00
Hybrid technology offers better long-term savings.
8
Tesla Model Y
A
Summary: Advanced safety features, including Tesla’s Autopilot system.
A-
Summary: Spacious, minimalist interior with high-tech features and comfortable seating.
A
Summary: Cutting-edge tech with over-the-air updates, Autopilot, and a large touchscreen interface.
A
Summary: Quick acceleration and smooth handling, thanks to the electric powertrain.
A
Summary: All-electric driving with excellent efficiency and long range.
A-
Summary: Spacious cabin and flexible seating, though slightly less roomy than larger SUVs.
A
Summary: Class-leading cargo space with both front and rear trunks.
A
Summary: Tesla’s Autopilot offers semi-autonomous driving capabilities.
A
The Tesla Model Y excels with cutting-edge technology, great performance, and top-notch safety features. Its long range, spacious cargo area, and strong resale value make it a leading choice among electric SUVs, though its higher upfront cost may be a consideration for some buyers.
$4,000.00
Electricity is cheaper than gas, leading to significant savings over time.
$3,000.00
EVs have fewer moving parts, resulting in lower maintenance costs.
$18,000.00
Tesla vehicles tend to hold their value well due to strong demand and brand recognition.
$2,000.00
Not eligible for used EV tax credit.
$36,000.00
Long-term savings due to low fuel and maintenance costs, along with strong resale value.
There are no rows in this table
Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.
This is not the way.
Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (
CtrlP
) instead.