Explore

7: The High Bar: Finding Your Signal in the Noise of Today's SaaS Landscape

In this episode of TinySeed Tales, we reconnect with Colleen Schnettler after a four-month hiatus, witnessing her evolution as a solo founder navigating the challenging terrain of product-market fit. From a pivotal retreat in the woods to landing her first paying customer, Colleen's journey illustrates the realities of building in today's hyper-competitive market where polished products are the norm and finding your unique angle is harder than ever.

The Initial Vision: Tools for Engineering Managers

When we last heard from Colleen, she was developing an AI-powered tool aimed at engineering managers that would allow non-technical team members to build their own database reports. Despite early enthusiasm, the momentum quickly dissipated:

"It kind of felt like I had more of an 'oh gee whiz, this is cool' and not a 'wow, this is actually a useful product I'm going to integrate into my workflow.'"

Despite her efforts to improve the user experience—adding suggested questions based on database schema and shortening the "time to wow"—engineering managers and developers weren't integrating it into their workflows. The painful reality emerged: her solution lacked a unique angle in the crowded embedded reporting space, where established competitors already offered polished alternatives.

The Turning Point: Reflection in the Woods

Faced with this stagnation, Colleen reached a crossroads that many founders encounter—persist, pivot, or abandon the idea entirely. Her response was both radical and refreshing:

"I went and spent a week in the woods, and that gave me some time to really think about, do I want to pursue this embedded reporting idea? Do I want to stick with this idea and try another take on it? Do I want to shut the business down?"

This deliberate disconnection wasn't an escape but a strategic pause that yielded clarity. The woods provided the space Colleen needed to see beyond immediate frustrations and recognize the value still hidden in her core concept:

"What I landed on is I'm not done with this idea yet. I want to take another swing at it, come approach it from a different direction."

Strategic Pivot: Marketing Analysts as the New Target

With renewed determination, Colleen hired a marketing coach whose insight proved pivotal. Having previously worked as a marketing analyst, he immediately recognized the value in her tool:

"I literally would've bought this tool. This was a problem I ran into all the time where I needed data from my database."

This revelation sparked a significant shift—Colleen decided to target marketing data analysts instead of engineering managers. These professionals are "marketing first" but need data to drive decisions and improve campaigns. The alignment felt natural for Colleen, combining her developer background with a genuine interest in marketing:

"Marketing I think is really good for me because I'm a developer and I'm really, really interested in the marketing space. It's something I really want to learn."

Finding Traction: The First Paying Customer

With her new focus, Colleen launched a newsletter teaching marketers SQL, conducted LinkedIn outreach, and refined her product. The effort yielded a breakthrough—her first paying customer at $59/month, just two weeks before the interview.

The circumstances were both humbling and validating. Despite the customer's blunt critique of the UI, they still subscribed:

"What's interesting about this person is I got on a call with them and they hate my UI... But I mean, this is still the wild west."

This paradox revealed an important truth: when you solve a genuine pain point, customers will pay despite imperfections. The product—a chat interface that turns questions into SQL queries, generates charts, and builds dashboards—was functional but unpolished. Yet it solved a real problem for at least one person willing to pay.

The Reality of Today's Market: No Room for Mediocrity

A recurring theme throughout Colleen's story is the relentless competition and elevated standards of today's SaaS landscape. She discovered that every niche she explored, no matter how obscure, already had multiple competitors with robust, well-designed products:

"No matter what you think is unique, it's probably not. Someone's probably doing it with more money and better UI. So you really just have to put the work in to make the product better. The product development has to be a continuous cycle."

This observation underscores a harsh reality for solo founders: the bar for product quality continues to rise, and the days of gaining traction with a rough MVP may be over:

"The bar for product is so high in today's market, or at least my solution is not compelling enough to have a low bar."

The Road Ahead: Six Months to Find Signal

With approximately six months of runway remaining, Colleen faces a critical period. She's still in the exploration phase, trying to identify the precise pain point or underserved niche where her tool can truly shine:

"What can I do? What reports can I build with this? And you also have a live shareable link. And so one of the things I've thought about is you can do triggers, you could do triggers off your database, which is actually something I'm really excited about."

Rob Walling offers perspective on Colleen's path forward, suggesting that success will likely come not from inventing a new category but from finding an existing tool that's overpriced or doesn't work well for a specific segment:

"It won't be inventing a new category or it won't be building something that has no competition. It will be figuring out... What tools do they use today that they're already paying for that are not good, that are either way overpriced?"

Key Takeaways for Solo Founders

Strategic Retreats Drive Clarity: Taking deliberate time away from day-to-day operations can provide the perspective needed to make pivotal decisions.

Pivot with Evidence, Not Just Hope: Colleen's shift to marketing analysts wasn't based on whim but on direct feedback from someone who would have been a customer.

Personal Alignment Matters: Choosing a market that aligns with your interests (marketing, in Colleen's case) creates natural momentum and enthusiasm that sustains you through challenges.

First Customers Can Be Critical: Don't expect perfect product-love from early adopters—they may hate your UI but still pay for the value you provide.

Product Quality Is Non-Negotiable: Today's market demands increasingly polished products, even from solo founders and early-stage startups.

Continuous Iteration Is Essential: Product development isn't a one-time effort but an ongoing cycle of improvement based on market feedback.

Find Your Wedge in Crowded Markets: Success doesn't require creating something entirely new but identifying specific weaknesses in established solutions.

Notable Quotes

“No matter what you think is unique, it's probably not. Someone's probably doing it with more money and better UI. So you really just have to put the work in to make the product better."

Colleen's sobering assessment of today's competitive landscape reminds founders that differentiation requires relentless improvement.

"I went and spent a week in the woods... What I landed on is I'm not done with this idea yet. I want to take another swing at it, come approach it from a different direction."

This moment captures the value of stepping back to gain perspective—sometimes the best strategic decisions come from leaving the battlefield briefly.

"What's interesting about this person is I got on a call with them and they hate my UI... but they needed to run more queries."

A powerful reminder that solving a genuine pain point can overcome UI shortcomings—functionality sometimes trumps form when addressing real needs.

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.