Explore

9: The Hope That Kills You: Knowing When to Shut Down Your Startup

In this emotionally charged season finale of TinySeed Tales, Colleen Schnettler makes the difficult decision to shut down Hello Query after years of effort and limited traction. Despite tripling her Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) to $540 and seeing some promising signs, she concludes there isn't a clear, repeatable path to sustainable growth. The episode offers a raw, unfiltered look at one of entrepreneurship's hardest moments—knowing when to walk away.

The Numbers Behind the Decision

Colleen begins with what should be good news: she has tripled her MRR since her last conversation with host Rob Walling. However, the reality behind this growth reveals why metrics alone don't tell the full story:

"Every single one of those three sales, so that's three new customers since we last spoke... Every single one was horrendously painful. I mean, it was follow up and follow up and follow up and onboarding calls and back and forth, and I just don't see a repeatable path to getting new customers."

While Hello Query as a specific implementation was only 10-12 months old (following a complete restart), the core idea had been pursued for nearly three years. With her TinySeed funding runway ending in December 2024, Colleen faced a critical calculation of opportunity cost versus potential.

The Emotional Rollercoaster of Shutting Down

The decision to shut down evolved over months of internal debate, with each small win reigniting hope:

"It's the hope that kills you, man, every month starting in November, I was like, I'm going to shut it down at end of November and then I'd get a new customer December. I'm going to shut it down, got a new customer."

This cycle made the decision particularly challenging. Colleen articulates the founder's dilemma perfectly:

"What is so hard about this decision is it actually might kind of be starting to work. And you always worry, right? You always worry. You're like, am I just one quarter away?"

Yet after three years of "a never-ending slog," exhaustion began to outweigh optimism. Colleen didn't want another side project—she wanted meaningful growth:

"I don't want to have a five year side project. This is so important to me. I have so many friends and good for them that works with their life... I have a five-year side project that makes $2,000 a month, right? And it hasn't grown and it just sits there. I don't want another one of those. I want to outpaced success."

Why Hello Query Didn't Work

The Co-Founder Split

Losing her co-founder (Aaron), who was the database expert, created a fundamental rupture in the business:

"He was the database expert, and sometimes I wonder if he was still working with me, we would have his kind of database clout to be like, he said, it's safe and everyone trusts him when it comes to databases."

The split forced Colleen to start completely from scratch:

"When he left, we literally lost anything he had created. I was completely starting over from scratch. I didn't have a half build application. I didn't have a design. I was just starting over completely from scratch."

She reflects that better communication about goals and expectations could have prevented this outcome—a lesson she'll carry forward.

The "Nerd Famous" False Signal

One of the most insightful revelations was how being well-known in their communities ("nerd famous") created misleading market signals:

"Both my co-founder and I were very well known in our respective communities. We both spoke at conferences, we had a podcast. People loved us. And I think that brought us false positive signals because the reason after he quit, the reason I kept going with this idea is because it felt like we had all of these people who had said they were really interested."

Reality proved quite different:

"I think I continued down this path because I thought I had a list of 20 people ready to buy. Literally in close, I have this list of 20 people that says ready to buy. Do you know how many of those people actually bought? One."

The 5% close rate on her "ready to buy" list highlighted a crucial lesson:

"If you're popular in your community, you do courses, you do coaching, that's how you capitalize on popularity. And we were trying to build a SaaS and popularity doesn't matter when you build a SaaS."

Execution Speed and Timing

Looking back, Colleen identifies specific tactical regrets:

"I don't think we executed fast enough that first year. And that's a very practical thing, but we didn't execute on the code front. We were building this list of people who wanted the thing, and we didn't ship the thing fast enough."

She also notes she would have "started cold outreach a year earlier" and avoided getting stuck in "corner cases" that delayed launching.

Opportunity Cost vs. Sunk Cost

A pivotal moment in Colleen's decision-making was recognizing the sunk cost fallacy at play:

"I have come so far, but also sunk cost fallacy. I can make a lot of more money doing other things. And that's become so obvious to me recently that it's like, do I really want to continue to pour my heart and soul and my time into this thing when people kind of seem interested?"

The contrast between Hello Query's slow growth and other opportunities became stark when she launched a new venture.

The Silver Lining: SaaS Marketing Gym

While Hello Query didn't achieve the desired success, Colleen has already found a promising path forward with SaaS Marketing Gym, a coaching business founded with copywriter Leanna Patch. The contrast in results was dramatic:

"My SaaS has made $1,200 in the past year. This thing made $12,000 in four days."

This new venture, focused on founder coaching with an emphasis on marketing strategies, demonstrated what "outpaced success" could actually look like—validating her decision to pivot.

Final Reflections

Despite the disappointment, Colleen maintains perspective and pride in her efforts:

"I gave this business everything I have and then some. So I am proud of the effort I put in and the work and the dedication I've had towards this business. And unfortunately it didn't go my way this time, but hopefully next time it will."

Rob Walling reinforces an important philosophy for founders facing setbacks, referencing football coach Bill Walsh's wisdom:

"The outcome is actually separate from the inputs... I controlled what I could control and let the score take care of itself."

Colleen echoes this sentiment:

"I controlled everything I could control for, and I can't control how many people sign up... I think there has to be an aspect of luck, a small aspect of luck here. And I didn't get lucky, but maybe next time I will."

Key Takeaways for Solo Founders

Beware the "Nerd Famous" Effect: Popularity in tech communities can create false signals; interest isn't the same as buying intent.

Shipping Speed Matters: Don't wait for perfection—launch quickly and iterate based on actual customer feedback.

Address Co-Founder Misalignments Early: Have honest conversations about goals and expectations before they become critical issues.

Recognize the Difference Between Traction and Struggle: If growth is painfully slow despite extensive effort, it may not be a viable business.

Watch for the "Hope Cycle": Be wary of clinging to a business because of sporadic wins that restart the hope cycle.

Calculate Opportunity Cost Honestly: Consider what else you could build with your time and energy versus continuing a slow-growth venture.

Separate Inputs from Outcomes: Success requires hard work, skill, and luck—control what you can and recognize what you can't.

It's Okay to Walk Away: Sometimes the best path forward is to apply your lessons to a new venture.

Notable Quotes

"It's the hope that kills you, man, every month starting in November, I was like, I'm going to shut it down at end of November and then I'd get a new customer... I'm going to shut it down, got a new customer." — Colleen describing the emotional cycle that made the decision so difficult

"I don't want to have a five year side project... I want to outpaced success." — Colleen explaining her motivation to avoid a business that merely survives but doesn't thrive

"My SaaS has made $1,200 in the past year. This thing made $12,000 in four days." — Colleen contrasting Hello Query with her new venture, SaaS Marketing Gym

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.