Student Experience
Report or Presentation
Encourages students to reflect on their simulation experience and what they learned, and then organize and present their thoughts. Reflection is very useful in experiential learning. Report-based assessment is also more familiar to students.
Assessment requires the instructor or teaching assistant to review reports, which can be more subjective and time-consuming.
Not as accurate for measuring participation and performance as other assessment methods.
Maximum fairness with results completely in student control. Accomplishing specific measurable goals demonstrates satisfactory levels of time commitment and performance.
May not motivate students to push further with experimentation and discovery
More competitive and performance based.
Some students may not like having their performance compared to other students.