Comprehensive Overview of Vaginitis in Nonpregnant Patients
This article, "ACOG PRACTICE BULLETIN Clinical Management Guidelines for Obstetrician–Gynecologists," offers guidance on diagnosing and treating various types of vaginitis in nonpregnant patients.
Background
Vaginitis, characterized by inflammation or infection of the vagina, presents with symptoms such as itching, burning, irritation, pain during intercourse, abnormal discharge, and a "fishy" odor.
These symptoms are frequent reasons for visits to obstetrician-gynecologists.
Accurately diagnosing the cause is crucial for successful treatment.
The most prevalent causes include:
Vulvovaginal candidiasis (17–39% of cases)
Bacterial vaginosis (22–50% of cases)
Trichomoniasis (4–35% of cases)
Other causes include vulvar skin diseases, desquamative inflammatory vaginitis, and genitourinary syndrome of menopause.
Role of Estrogen in Vaginal Health
Estrogen significantly impacts the vaginal environment.
During reproductive years, estrogen elevates glycogen levels in vaginal epithelial cells, promoting lactobacilli colonization.
Lactobacilli produce lactic acid, lowering vaginal pH to below 4.5, which inhibits pathogenic organism growth.
The normal vaginal flora is diverse and may include organisms like Gardnerella vaginalis, Escherichia coli, group B streptococci, genital Mycoplasma species, and Candida albicans.
In prepubertal girls and postmenopausal women, estrogen deficiency hinders the normal growth of vaginal bacteria.
Microscopy often reveals few epithelial cells and bacteria in these populations.
The vaginal epithelium is thin, the pH is higher than 4.5 due to reduced lactobacilli, and the growth of bacteria associated with bacterial vaginosis and yeast forms is uncommon.
Bacterial Vaginosis
Bacterial vaginosis is not a true infection or inflammatory condition. It's a shift in the vaginal microbiome with an overgrowth of anaerobic organisms like G. vaginalis, Bacteroides species, Peptostreptococcus species, Fusobacterium species, Prevotella species, and Atopobium vaginae, along with a decrease in hydrogen peroxide-producing lactobacilli.
It is the most common cause of abnormal vaginal discharge in women of reproductive age.
Prevalence is higher in Black, Hispanic, and Mexican American women.
Risk factors include race/ethnicity, age, douching, and sexual activity.
While associated with sexual activity in heterosexual and lesbian couples, it is not a sexually transmitted infection (STI) in the traditional sense as it is not directly caused by a single pathogen.
Nonpregnant women with bacterial vaginosis have a higher risk of pelvic inflammatory disease (PID), postprocedural gynecologic infections, and STIs like HIV and herpes simplex virus type 2.
Many women with bacterial vaginosis are asymptomatic.
Symptomatic women often experience abnormal vaginal discharge and a fishy odor, particularly after intercourse or menstruation.
Trichomoniasis
Trichomoniasis, caused by the protozoan parasite Trichomonas vaginalis, is the most common nonviral STI in the United States.
African American women are disproportionately affected.
Risk factors include having multiple sex partners, low socioeconomic status, and douching.
Trichomoniasis is linked to PID, posthysterectomy cuff cellulitis, HIV, and other STIs.
Over half of infected individuals are asymptomatic or have minimal symptoms.
Symptomatic women may report abnormal vaginal discharge, itching, burning, or bleeding after intercourse.
While classified as an STI, recent diagnosis doesn't necessarily indicate recent acquisition due to the possibility of prolonged asymptomatic carriage in both men and women.
Vulvovaginal Candidiasis
Vulvovaginal candidiasis involves inflammation and infection of the vagina with Candida species.
It is the second most common cause of vaginitis.
Nearly half of females experience at least one episode in their lifetime.
Presentations range from asymptomatic colonization to severe symptoms such as burning, itching, swelling, painful urination, pain during intercourse, and abnormal discharge.
It is uncommon in prepubertal girls and postmenopausal women not using estrogen and is often overdiagnosed in these groups.
Initial Evaluation of Vaginitis
Recommended initial evaluation includes:
Complete medical history
Physical examination of the vulva and vagina
Clinical testing of vaginal discharge (pH, KOH whiff test, microscopy)
History should focus on:
Location, description, and duration of symptoms
Sexual history
Self-treatment with over-the-counter or prescription medications
Vulvovaginal hygiene practices (shaving, douching)
Underlying medical conditions (diabetes, HIV, inflammatory bowel disease)
Relationship of symptoms to the menstrual cycle
Physical examination:
Begins with a thorough assessment of the vulva and perianal skin.
Vulvar dermatoses may present with redness, hypopigmentation, papules, plaques, melanosis, swelling, or architectural changes indicative of chronic inflammation.
Candidiasis and trichomoniasis can cause vulvar redness and swelling in addition to vaginal findings, while bacterial vaginosis does not affect the vulva.
Speculum examination is performed to collect vaginal discharge samples for clinical testing.
While the discharge appearance may offer clues, it is not diagnostic on its own.
Clinical Testing:
pH testing: Swab should be obtained from the mid-vaginal wall to avoid false elevations from cervical mucus, blood, semen, lubricants, etc.
KOH whiff test (amine odor test)
Microscopic examination with saline and KOH
FDA-approved commercial tests can be used when pH paper, KOH, and microscopy are unavailable.
Diagnosis and Treatment of Bacterial Vaginosis
Diagnosis:
Clinical presentation: Watery, gray, homogenous discharge, often with a fishy odor.
Recommended diagnostic methods: Amsel criteria or Gram stain with Nugent scoring.
Routine bacterial culture is not recommended as the normal vaginal flora is heterogeneous.
Overdiagnosis is common, so clinical correlation is crucial to prevent unnecessary treatment.
Amsel Criteria (requires 3 out of 4 criteria for diagnosis):
Homogenous, thin, white-gray discharge coating the vaginal walls
More than 20% clue cells on saline microscopy (vaginal squamous cells with adherent coccobacilli)
Vaginal pH greater than 4.5
Positive KOH whiff test (fishy odor before or after mixing discharge with KOH)
Gram Stain with Nugent Scoring:
Considered the gold standard but primarily used in research settings.
Assigns a score based on bacterial morphotypes seen on Gram stain of vaginal secretions.
Scores of 0–3: Normal flora
Scores of 4–6: Intermediate flora
Scores of 7–10: Bacterial vaginosis flora
Commercial Tests:
May be considered when microscopy is unavailable.
Examples include direct DNA probe assays for G. vaginalis and chromogenic point-of-care assays detecting sialidase activity.
The diagnostic value of tests identifying only a single organism is still being investigated.
Multiplex PCR panel tests combining PCR and DNA probe technology show promise as alternatives to microscopy. They can determine the ratio of lactobacilli to bacterial vaginosis-associated bacteria.
Treatment:
Symptomatic women should be treated to reduce overgrowth of anaerobic bacteria and allow lactobacilli to predominate.
Treatment may also reduce the risk of transmitting or acquiring other STIs.
Patients with bacterial vaginosis should be tested for HIV and other STIs.
Recommended treatments:
Oral or intravaginal metronidazole
Intravaginal clindamycin
Alternative treatments:
Oral secnidazole
Oral tinidazole
Oral clindamycin
Choice of therapy should be individualized based on patient preference, cost, convenience, adherence, ease of use, and previous treatment history.
Patients using intravaginal medications may want to avoid tampons to ensure proper drug distribution.
Management of Recurrent Bacterial Vaginosis:
Recurrent bacterial vaginosis is defined as at least three documented, separate episodes within a year.
Follow-up with rescreening is not necessary if symptoms resolve after treatment.
Recurrence is possible in up to 30% of patients within 3 months and 58% within 12 months.
Possible contributing factors include douching, frequent sexual activity, prior bacterial vaginosis, persistent pathogenic bacteria, or failure to reestablish a lactobacillus-dominant vaginal flora.
Management options for recurrent cases:
Twice-weekly suppressive metronidazole gel for 16 weeks after acute episode treatment
Changing the antibiotic or extending the treatment course
Diagnosis and Treatment of Trichomoniasis
Diagnosis:
Clinical presentation: Elevated vaginal pH, inflammatory discharge (potentially green-yellow and bubbly).
Preferred diagnostic test: Nucleic acid amplification testing (NAAT), due to its high sensitivity and specificity.
Microscopy has limited sensitivity (50–60%) and is not recommended.
Alternative options: FDA-approved commercial tests or vaginal culture.
NAAT:
Highly sensitive compared to microscopy.
Can be performed on vaginal, cervical, or urine specimens with high sensitivity and specificity.
Commercial Tests:
DNA probe technology can detect T. vaginalis in vaginal secretions.
Multiplex PCR panel tests that combine DNA probe and amplification technology are comparable to reference standards and can also screen for G. vaginalis and C. albicans.
Antigen-Detection Testing:
Rapid point-of-care option with results in approximately 10 minutes.
Culture:
Previously the gold standard, but now superseded by molecular methods.
Inconvenient, takes at least 5 days, and often requires special media.
Treatment:
Recommended treatment: Oral nitroimidazoles (metronidazole or tinidazole).
While a single dose of metronidazole has been the preferred regimen, recent studies suggest a 7-day course is more effective.
Metronidazole is generally cheaper than tinidazole but has more gastrointestinal side effects.
Alcohol should be avoided during treatment and for 24 hours after metronidazole or 72 hours after tinidazole due to the risk of a disulfiram-like reaction.
Metronidazole gel is ineffective for T. vaginalis infections.
Patients with metronidazole allergy should be referred for desensitization.
Low-level metronidazole resistance may occur, but high-level resistance is rare.
In cases of suspected resistance, tinidazole may be effective.
If retreatment fails and adherence is confirmed, culture and susceptibility testing should be considered.
Retesting within 3 months is recommended due to high recurrence rates.
Diagnosis and Treatment of Vulvovaginal Candidiasis
Diagnosis:
Clinical symptoms alone are unreliable for diagnosis.
Confirmation requires one of the following in a symptomatic patient:
Visualization of spores, pseudohyphae, or hyphae on wet mount microscopy
Positive vaginal fungal culture or commercial test for Candida species
Microscopy:
Convenient and cost-effective, but sensitivity is only 50–70%.
Self-treatment before evaluation can hinder visualization.
Culture:
Preferred for confirming yeast presence when microscopy is negative.
Helpful for identifying non-albicans Candida species.
Useful for evaluating recurrent or resistant cases.
Important to correlate with symptoms as cultures may be positive in asymptomatic individuals.
Commercial Tests:
PCR tests offer rapid results but are expensive and not FDA-approved for yeast detection.
DNA probe technology kits are available, but some lack speciation capabilities.
Newer DNA probe tests with PCR can differentiate Candida species into three groups and may be useful for complicated yeast infections.
Classification and Treatment:
Vulvovaginal candidiasis is classified as uncomplicated or complicated based on clinical presentation, microbiology, host factors, and treatment response.
Complicated cases require more aggressive treatment.
Uncomplicated Vulvovaginal Candidiasis:
Recommended treatment: Intravaginal azole therapy or oral fluconazole.
Treatment choice should be individualized.
Over-the-counter imidazole creams and suppositories are readily available, but many prefer a single oral fluconazole tablet.
Topical treatments may cause burning and irritation.
Oral fluconazole is generally well-tolerated but may cause mild, self-limiting side effects like gastrointestinal upset, headache, and elevated liver enzymes.
Complicated Vulvovaginal Candidiasis:
Defined as:
Recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis (4 or more infections in 12 months)
Severe symptoms
Infection with non-albicans Candida species
Infection in an immunocompromised woman (e.g., HIV, immunosuppressive medications, diabetes)
Culture is essential for identifying the yeast species.
Oral fluconazole is effective for complicated infections with C. albicans, but resistance has been documented.
Culture and susceptibility testing are recommended for persistent symptoms after treatment or when non-albicans isolates are identified.
Recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis:
Diagnosis requires documentation of infections with objective data, including yeast speciation by culture.
Extended antifungal treatment is recommended.
Suppressive therapy with weekly intravaginal or oral azoles improves cure rates and reduces recurrence.
Prolonged fluconazole treatment (150 mg weekly for 6 months) effectively controlled over 90% of recurrent episodes and offered prolonged protection in about 50% of patients with C. albicans infections.
Intermittent topical agents like clotrimazole are alternatives for patients who cannot or will not take fluconazole.
Severe vulvovaginal candidiasis:
Characterized by vulvar symptoms like redness, erosion, fissures, and swelling.
Requires prolonged treatment with topical intravaginal azole for 10–14 days or two to three doses of oral fluconazole taken 3 days apart.
Non-albicans Candida species:
Less responsive to topical imidazoles or oral fluconazole.
Suspect in women with persistent symptoms after uncomplicated vulvovaginal candidiasis treatment.
Vaginal fungal culture is recommended to identify the species.
Intravaginal boric acid (600 mg daily for at least 14 days) is effective for C. glabrata and other atypical species.
Topical flucytosine is an alternative but often expensive.
Treatment Without Examination
Self-diagnosis of vaginitis is not recommended due to limited accuracy and nonspecific symptoms.
Women with vaginitis symptoms, particularly those who have self-treated for presumed candidiasis without success, should seek clinical evaluation.
In-office examination is necessary before treatment.
Adverse Effects of Nonprescription Antifungal Use
Topical nonprescription antifungals generally have cure rates and adverse effects similar to prescription therapies.
Failure to respond to initial treatment warrants clinical evaluation.
Contact dermatitis (burning and irritation) may occur in about 5% of users.
Using antifungals for the wrong condition or experiencing treatment failure can delay diagnosis and appropriate treatment.
Excessive use of nonprescription antifungals can lead to unnecessary costs.
Vaginitis Findings on Cervical Cytology
Pap tests are unreliable for diagnosing vaginitis.
Diagnostic confirmation is recommended for incidental findings of candidiasis, bacterial vaginosis, or trichomoniasis on Pap tests.
Candidiasis:
Vaginal Candida species are present in 20–30% of asymptomatic women.
Treatment is not indicated for asymptomatic cases.
Symptomatic patients with positive Pap results should undergo confirmatory testing.
Bacterial Vaginosis:
Pap tests have low sensitivity for bacterial vaginosis.
Confirmatory testing is needed in symptomatic patients with suggestive findings.
Asymptomatic individuals do not require evaluation or treatment.
Trichomoniasis:
Pap tests have low sensitivity for detecting trichomonads.
Confirmatory testing is necessary if trichomonads are suspected.
Treatment is recommended for confirmed cases.
Probiotics and Nonmedical Approaches
Probiotics (vaginal or oral) and nonmedical therapies are not recommended for treating or preventing vaginitis.
Candidiasis:
Lactobacillus products (oral or vaginal) are ineffective for treatment or prevention.
Other nonmedical therapies (yogurt, garlic, tea tree oil, low-carbohydrate diet, douching) lack sufficient data on efficacy and are not FDA-regulated.
Bacterial vaginosis:
Probiotics are not recommended for treatment, augmentation of antimicrobial therapy, or maintaining vaginal balance.
Studies have not shown benefit from vaginal lactobacillus supplements, alone or with antibiotics.
Trichomoniasis:
Nitroimidazoles are the only recommended and effective treatment.
Referral for desensitization is recommended for intolerant or allergic patients.
Treatment of Sexual Partners
Trichomoniasis:
Current sexual partners should be treated presumptively and abstain from sexual activity until they complete therapy and are asymptomatic.
Partner management reduces transmission and recurrence.
Bacterial vaginosis:
Data do not support partner treatment for affecting relapse or remission rates.
Uncomplicated vulvovaginal candidiasis:
Partner treatment is not necessary.
Summary of Recommendations
Level A (Good and Consistent Scientific Evidence):
Amsel criteria or Gram stain with Nugent scoring is recommended for diagnosing bacterial vaginosis.
Oral or intravaginal metronidazole or intravaginal clindamycin is recommended for treating bacterial vaginosis. Alternatives include oral secnidazole, tinidazole, or clindamycin.
NAAT is recommended for diagnosing trichomoniasis.
Oral nitroimidazoles are recommended for treating trichomoniasis.
Diagnosis of symptomatic vulvovaginal candidiasis requires either visualization of fungal elements on microscopy or a positive culture/commercial test for Candida species.
Extended antifungal treatment is recommended for recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis.
Level B (Limited or Inconsistent Scientific Evidence):
Retesting within 3 months after trichomoniasis treatment is recommended due to high recurrence rates.
Pap tests are unreliable for vaginitis diagnosis, and confirmatory testing is needed for incidental findings.
Level C (Consensus and Expert Opinion):
Complete history, physical examination, and vaginal discharge testing (pH, KOH whiff test, microscopy) are recommended for initial vaginitis evaluation.
Intravaginal azole therapy or oral fluconazole is recommended for treating uncomplicated vulvovaginal candidiasis.
Self-diagnosis is not recommended.
Probiotics and nonmedical therapies are not recommended.
Partners of women with confirmed trichomoniasis should be treated presumptively.