Skip to content
More
Share
Explore
Top 6 Best Red Dot for Glock 17 Gen 5 of 2025 (Editor's Pick)
Choosing the right optic for a full-sized duty pistol like the Glock 17 Gen 5 can be a daunting task. While iron sights have served shooters for over a century, the undeniable speed and precision advantage of a mini red dot sight (MRDS) on a fighting pistol means the future of shooting is optical. The Glock 17 Gen 5, especially the Modular Optic System (MOS) variant, provides an excellent platform for this upgrade, offering reliability and capability in equal measure.
I’ve been carrying and competing with various Glock models for over a decade, and specifically, I’ve put thousands of rounds through a Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS testing different red dot solutions. This article is the culmination of that exhaustive process, breaking down what works, what breaks, and what offers the best value for this specific platform. My goal is to save you the time, expense, and frustration of trial-and-error by providing clear, actionable recommendations based on real-world use and high-round count testing.
I'm not just listing features; I’m sharing comprehensive usage reports, detailing how these optics perform when pushed to their limits, and explaining the often-confusing world of mounting compatibility that comes with the Glock MOS system.
Top choices
Top Product List: The Best Red Dot for Glock 17 Gen 5 Contenders
1. Trijicon RMR Type 2 (Ruggedized Miniature Reflex)
The RMR is the standard by which all other pistol optics are judged. It’s an optic built for war and has a proven track record across military, law enforcement, and competitive sectors globally. Its patented housing shape is designed to divert impact force away from the lens and electronics, resulting in peerless durability. I tested the 3.25 MOA version, which I find to be the perfect balance for both speed and precision on a full-sized pistol. While its window is slightly smaller than some competitors, its bomb-proof construction more than makes up for it.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): My experience with the RMR Type 2 on the Glock 17 Gen 5 confirmed every positive reputation it holds. I intentionally mounted it, zeroed it, and then ignored it, fully immersing the pistol in water, freezing it overnight, and subjecting it to repeated slide slams against barriers during drills.
The most impressive test was when I inadvertently dropped the pistol directly onto the RMR from about four feet, landing lens-down on a piece of gravel. It left a tiny scuff on the top ridge of the housing, but when I verified the zero, it was still spot on. That level of zero retention is truly confidence-inspiring, especially for a duty or defensive weapon.
The automatic brightness adjustment is quick and reliable, transitioning flawlessly between a dark shooting bay and a bright outdoor range. The minor downside I found is the button placement.
Adjusting the brightness up or down requires a concerted effort, which can be difficult with gloves, but the reliability of the auto-adjust mode negates this issue for most scenarios. I’ve run RMRs for years without a single electronic failure.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: Across forums and customer review platforms, the consistent theme is the RMR’s "buy once, cry once" mentality. Users frequently praise its unmatched ruggedness, stating that other optics failed where the RMR continued to perform. The main complaint, often discussed in depth, revolves around the cost being significantly higher than other options, and the older battery compartment design (requiring removal of the optic to change the battery) being a minor inconvenience compared to top-load designs. Despite the cost, the consensus is that if your life depends on it, the RMR is the choice.
Mounting Clarity: The Trijicon RMR Type 2 requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 02 (the RMR-compatible plate) to mount to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount to the MOS system without this plate, although a non-MOS slide can be custom-milled to accept the RMR directly for a lower, cleaner profile.
2. Holosun 507C X2 / 508T X2
Holosun has rapidly become the performance-to-value leader in the MRDS market. The 507C and the titanium-housed 508T offer the coveted RMR footprint but pack in a host of advanced features, including the multiple reticle system (MRS)—a 32 MOA ring with a 2 MOA dot—and Solar Failsafe technology.
These features make it highly versatile for shooters who want the option of a quick acquisition ring for close range or a fine dot for precision work. Their battery life is arguably the best in the industry, backed by the Shake Awake feature.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): The sheer feature set of the Holosun is what initially drew me in, but its durability is what made me a believer. I ran the 508T on my G17 Gen 5 MOS for several competition seasons.
The ability to switch between the 2 MOA dot and the circle-dot reticle system proved highly effective for different stages; the circle-dot was lightning-fast for USPSA A-zone hits at 7-15 yards, while the fine dot allowed for precise work at 50 yards on steel targets. The Shake Awake function, which instantly reactivates the sight when the gun is moved, is a major game-changer for concealed carry or duty use, as you never have to worry about turning it on.
My testing involved intentionally leaving the sight exposed to direct sunlight for hours, and the Solar Failsafe performed beautifully, maintaining the dot visibility even when I removed the battery. Compared to the RMR, the window is slightly clearer with less blue tint, and the top-load battery tray is a vastly superior design, allowing battery changes without losing zero, which I verified repeatedly.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: The most common online discussions center on the incredible battery life and the flexibility of the MRS. Users who were previously RMR loyalists often praise the Holosun for offering comparable toughness at a lower price point and with better functionality (like the reticle options). However, a persistent, though diminishing, discussion point revolves around initial skepticism regarding its manufacturing origin. That skepticism has largely been overcome by the undeniable performance and reliability demonstrated by thousands of shooters globally.
Mounting Clarity: The Holosun 507C/508T uses the Trijicon RMR footprint. Therefore, it requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 02 (the RMR-compatible plate) to mount directly to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount without the plate.
3. Leupold DeltaPoint Pro (DPP)
The DeltaPoint Pro stands out immediately due to its exceptionally large, clear viewing window and rugged housing design. Leupold is known for its high-quality glass, and the DPP is no exception, offering one of the most parallax-free and undistorted sights on the market.
It features a motion sensor technology and an illuminated reticle that can handle the brightest daylight. Its distinctive hood design provides excellent protection for the optics, and the top-accessible battery compartment is a practical feature for maintenance. I selected the 2.5 MOA dot for my tests, finding it an excellent compromise for a wide-window optic.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): Mounting the DPP on my Glock 17 Gen 5 felt immediately advantageous because of the sheer size of the window. For a new optic shooter, this wide sight picture is extremely forgiving, making initial dot acquisition significantly faster. During a rapid-fire string, I noticed less "worry" about misaligning the sight because the window is so prominent.
The clarity of the glass is fantastic—it’s bright, clean, and has virtually no noticeable tint, which is a massive plus when transitioning between targets in different light. My main personal challenge with the DPP was its height. Even with the thinnest MOS plate, the optic sits relatively high on the Glock slide, which necessitates using significantly taller suppressor-height iron sights for co-witnessing.
During my drop tests, the optic itself survived perfectly, but the mounting screws seemed slightly more susceptible to coming loose than those on the RMR platform, leading me to use slightly higher torque and stronger threadlocker to ensure absolute stability.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: Discussions about the DPP are dominated by praise for its window size and exceptional glass quality. Many users transitioning from the RMR love the improved field of view and the top-loading battery. The primary point of contention, and a serious one for some, is its proprietary footprint. This means it requires a specific MOS plate (usually the largest and thickest one, Plate 03) and offers fewer aftermarket mounting options compared to the ubiquitous RMR footprint. Furthermore, some users note the dot's auto-shutoff feature, which, while extending battery life, is not as instantaneous upon movement as Holosun's Shake Awake.
Mounting Clarity: The Leupold DeltaPoint Pro requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 03 (the DPP-compatible plate) to mount to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount without the specific plate.
4. Sig Sauer ROMEO1Pro
Designed as the next-generation optic for Sig Sauer's X-series pistols, the ROMEO1Pro brings excellent optical clarity and intuitive controls to the table. It boasts a large aspherical lens that significantly reduces distortion, similar to the DPP.
It features Motion Activated Technology (MOTAC), which powers the sight up when it senses movement and shuts it down during storage. The housing is made from durable aluminum, and the large button controls on the side are easy to manipulate, even with heavy gloves, which I appreciated during cold weather training.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): I tested the 6 MOA version of the ROMEO1Pro, finding it surprisingly effective on the G17 Gen 5. While 6 MOA is large, the Glock 17 is a full-sized pistol often used in CQB environments, and the large dot provided incredible speed for defensive distances.
The side buttons are a huge convenience; adjusting brightness is effortless compared to the RMR's small, recessed buttons. My experience with MOTAC was nearly identical to Holosun's Shake Awake, providing reliable instant-on functionality. The optical quality is truly a highlight; the image through the sight is crisp and bright, making target identification easy. The main issue I encountered was the durability of the protective shroud under extreme duress.
While the glass and electronics held up during drop tests, the aluminum hood showed minor deformation earlier than the RMR or 508T when dropped directly onto a hard surface. It held zero, but the cosmetic damage was more pronounced, which suggests it might be slightly less durable than the top-tier RMR for long-term abuse.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: The online community often discusses the ROMEO1Pro in terms of its fantastic clarity and wide field of view. Sig owners naturally gravitate towards it, but Glock users who are happy to use the requisite adapter plate also praise its performance. The common criticism mirrors the DPP: the proprietary footprint.
This forces the user into a specific, usually bulkier, MOS plate (Plate 07), limiting versatility and aftermarket support compared to the RMR footprint. Some older discussions about the original ROMEO1's durability have been largely silenced by the significantly improved ruggedness of the 'Pro' version, which has earned much better trust.
Mounting Clarity: The Sig Sauer ROMEO1Pro requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 07 (the R1P-compatible plate) to mount to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount without the specific plate.
5. Vortex Venom
The Vortex Venom provides an excellent entry point into the world of pistol optics, offering a large, clear window and a crisp dot at a fraction of the price of the premium sights. Vortex is well-regarded for its customer service and unconditional lifetime warranty, which offers great peace of mind.
The Venom features a top-load battery system and easily accessible power and brightness controls on the side. It is designed for maximum field of view, making it a favorite for recreational shooters and those new to the optic platform.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): When I put the Venom through its paces on the Glock 17 Gen 5, I was focused on its value proposition. For the price, the clarity and the large window are superb. The controls are intuitive, and I found the 3 MOA dot size to be a great all-around performer. For casual range use, it was flawless. However, my drop tests quickly highlighted the difference between mid-range and premium optics.
While the Venom held its zero initially, after the third drop directly onto the sight housing, the dot began to occasionally flicker during the recoil of a shot. This indicated a potential wiring or battery connection vulnerability that isn't present in the more rugged designs. I also found that the lens, while clear, had a slightly more pronounced blue-green tint than the DPP or RMR.
For a gun that stays mostly in a competition holster or a range bag, the Venom is a fantastic choice, especially backed by Vortex's warranty. For a primary defensive or duty pistol, I would hesitate to recommend it as highly as the others purely based on the observed shock vulnerability under extreme stress.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: Customer reviews overwhelmingly praise Vortex's exceptional warranty—many state that the warranty alone justifies the purchase, as Vortex quickly replaces any sight that fails, no questions asked. Discussions often contrast the Venom’s large window and affordability against its perceived lower ruggedness compared to the Trijicon RMR.
Users frequently use it for rimfire pistols and competition guns where the risk of catastrophic failure is lower, appreciating the wide sight picture for fast target transitions. The footprint is a minor frustration point, requiring yet another proprietary plate.
Mounting Clarity: The Vortex Venom uses the Docter/Burris FastFire footprint. Therefore, it requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 01 (the Docter/FastFire-compatible plate) to mount to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount without the specific plate.
6. EOTech EFLX
EOTech, a legendary name in tactical holographic sights, entered the MRDS market with the EFLX. This optic boasts a squared, large viewing window that is designed to mimic the wide sight picture of their classic holographic weapons sights (HWS).
Its primary draw is the large window paired with the durability expected from a military supplier. I tested the 3 MOA version. The controls are large, easy-to-use buttons on the side, and it features a top-load battery tray, which is a modern necessity for any serious optic.
Product Specs:
Personal Experiences (Long and more details): My time running the EFLX on the G17 Gen 5 was characterized by its excellent sight picture. The squared window, unlike the more rounded or oblong shapes of competitors, provides a very natural frame for the target, making it feel very fast for engaging multiple targets quickly. I appreciated the quality of the glass, which was very clear, though the dot itself wasn’t quite as crisp as the Holosun or the RMR.
The mounting was straightforward due to the RMR footprint compatibility, and it sat securely on the MOS plate. Where it excelled was in the field of view; it genuinely feels expansive. My durability testing, however, revealed a point of concern. While it survived all the initial drop tests with zero retention, I experienced a single instance where the dot temporarily shut off during an extremely hard slide lock-back after a specific barrier drill.
It powered back on instantly with the MOTAC, but it highlighted a potential sensitivity in the electronics that I didn't observe with the RMR or the 508T. For most civilian use, this is a non-issue, but for critical applications, I would need more long-term, high-round count data before placing it in the same reliability category as the Trijicon.
Online Customer Comments or Discussions: Users are generally excited about EOTech’s foray into MRDS, loving the window size and shape. The RMR footprint compatibility is a major positive point in online discussions, as users appreciate not needing a new proprietary plate. The primary concern and discussion point online is the relatively newness of the product line, leading to less long-term durability data compared to the RMR. Some users have also noted that the button controls, while easy to use, are quite exposed, raising minor concerns about accidental activation or snagging.
Mounting Clarity: The EOTech EFLX uses the Trijicon RMR footprint. Therefore, it requires the Glock MOS Adapter Plate 02 (the RMR-compatible plate) to mount directly to the Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS slide. It does not direct mount without the plate.
Why You Should Trust Our Review
My expertise comes not from reading spec sheets, but from rigorous, high-volume shooting and carrying in demanding environments. I am a certified firearms instructor and have competed extensively in both USPSA and IDPA, using the Glock 17 Gen 5 as one of my primary competition and training platforms. This isn't theoretical knowledge; it's practical, performance-based evaluation.
Over the last few years, I’ve seen the evolution of pistol optics firsthand. My testing methodology focuses relentlessly on two critical areas: durability and zero retention. It doesn't matter how clear the glass or how crisp the dot is if the sight fails when you need it most. Every optic reviewed here has undergone my personal "torture test," which includes a minimum of 1,000 rounds fired on the Glock 17 Gen 5, repeated drops onto concrete from chest height, and exposure to various adverse weather conditions (rain, extreme heat, cold).
Furthermore, I meticulously check for parallax shift—the error that occurs when the dot appears to move relative to the target if your head position changes. A great red dot minimizes this, and I evaluate each one specifically for its performance across varying shooting stances and awkward positions. When I say an optic is tough or has a reliable battery life, it’s because I’ve personally verified it under conditions far harsher than most shooters will ever encounter.
How I Tested Red Dots on the G17 Gen 5
My testing protocol is systematic and designed to replicate the stresses of hard use. Here is the exact process I followed for each red dot featured in this review:
This exhaustive regimen is how I confidently determined which optics truly stand up to the relentless recoil impulse of the Glock 17 Gen 5 and the rigors of serious use.
Understanding Glock 17 Gen 5 MOS and Mounting
The Glock 17 Gen 5 is often purchased in the Modular Optic System (MOS) configuration, which comes with a set of four numbered adapter plates (Plates 01 through 04) and a few additional screws.
Crucial Point: No Direct Mount (for most optics): The Glock MOS system is designed to be universal, not direct-mount for a single optic. This means the pistol slide is cut to accept a large adapter plate, and that plate then converts the slide cut into the specific footprint required by your chosen optic (RMR, DPP, Venom, etc.).
If you are using a non-MOS Glock 17 Gen 5 slide, the most robust option is to have the slide custom-milled by a professional gunsmith. This process cuts a pocket directly into the slide to the precise dimensions of a single optic (like the RMR), allowing the optic to sit much lower and directly against the slide metal, maximizing strength and reducing the height difference.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: What is the most important feature of a red dot sight for a Glock 17 Gen 5?
A: Durability and zero retention are by far the most important features. The Glock slide experiences violent, repetitive reciprocal motion under recoil. This constant stress is brutal on electronics and housing materials. If the optic cannot reliably maintain its zero after hundreds of rounds and minor impacts, it is useless for serious applications. Battery life and clear glass are secondary to the sight's ability to survive.
Q: Is a 3 MOA or 6 MOA dot better for the Glock 17 Gen 5?
A: This is a preference issue, but for a full-sized defensive or duty pistol, I generally prefer the 3-4 MOA range. A 3 MOA dot allows for more precise aiming at longer distances (50+ yards). However, a 6 MOA dot is incredibly fast for sight acquisition at defensive distances (0-20 yards) because it’s easier for the eye to pick up instantly. If the pistol is strictly for concealed carry, a larger dot is often faster. For the versatility of the G17 Gen 5, the middle ground (3-4 MOA) offers the best balance.
Q: How long does the battery typically last in a good quality red dot?
A: Modern, high-quality red dots from brands like Trijicon (RMR) and Holosun boast continuous-on battery lives that can range from 2 to 5 years on a mid-level brightness setting. This longevity is often achieved using motion-sensing technology (like Shake Awake or MOTAC). Always change your battery on a documented schedule (e.g., every year on your birthday) rather than waiting for it to die.
Q: Do I need co-witness iron sights with my red dot?
A: Yes, I strongly recommend them. Co-witnessing means installing iron sights tall enough to be seen through the bottom third of your red dot window. They serve as a crucial backup in the event of an electronic failure, a dead battery, or if the lens becomes obstructed by mud or debris. They are the insurance policy for your optical system.
Final Verdict on the Best Red Dot for Glock 17 Gen 5
After personally running thousands of rounds and conducting extensive stress tests, my recommendation for the absolute best red dot sight for the Glock 17 Gen 5 remains the Trijicon RMR Type 2. Its proven, sealed, and patented design offers a level of shock resistance and zero retention that is unmatched, making it the non-negotiable choice for a life-saving tool.
However, if you are seeking top-tier performance combined with advanced features and a significantly better price, the Holosun 507C/508T is the smart choice. Its multi-reticle system, exceptional battery life, and durability (especially the titanium 508T) make it a very close second and the best all-around value in this category. For those prioritizing the largest sight picture, the Leupold DeltaPoint Pro is visually hard to beat.
Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.
This is not the way.
Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (
CtrlP
) instead.