Rate Checkin

Gross Potential Rent (GPR): $126,088 (up from ~$117k at the start of August).

Physical Occupancy: 398 units, 51.8% occupied by unit count; 48.5% occupied by square footage. This is slightly down from earlier in the month (~52.6%), meaning occupancy has stalled despite higher posted rents.

Economic Occupancy: 34.2% – actual rent collections are far behind potential rent, indicating heavy vacancy and discounting.

Revenue: $40,357 MTD (vs. $33,006 in July), showing growth driven by higher rates, not more units filled.

Move-Ins vs. Move-Outs:

27 move-ins vs. 28 move-outs in August.

Net: -1 unit for the month, despite higher pricing.

Year-to-date: 294 move-ins vs. 54 move-outs, net +240.

Lead Volume: 38 leads in August (through the 27th), with a strong conversion rate (74%).

Move-In Trend: August slowed significantly compared to July (43 move-ins in July vs. only 27 so far in August).

Takeaway: The funnel is slowing after the rate increases. Leads are still coming in, but fewer are converting to rentals.

Self Storage Solutions (3.5 mi away):

10×10 climate units around $110–120/month.

Intro discounts available.

Likely ~75–80% occupied.

Five Star Storage (multiple sites):

10×10 climate units: ~$100–110/month.

10×20 units: ~$179–199.

Generally lower base rates, fewer advertised promos.

Premiere (Current):

10×10 climate units: $126–152 (39% occupancy on elevator-access units).

10×15 units: $163–189 (45–56% occupancy).

10×20 units: $221–265 (46–49% occupancy).

Current promos: 2 months at 50% off (mostly for upper floors).

Comparison: Premiere is the highest-priced facility in the market, particularly for medium and large units. Competitors are 10–30% lower in rate.

Pause Rate Increases: Pushing rates further is slowing occupancy gains – the property is stuck at ~52%.

Roll Back GPR to ~$119k: Align rates closer to the market to stimulate leasing.

Hold Rates on Small Units (5×5, 5×10): These are already ~90–95% occupied and less price-sensitive.

Focus on Occupancy: The priority is to lease up to 70–80%. Once stabilized, you can safely resume aggressive rate pushes.

Answer to Your Core Question:

The lead funnel and move-ins have slowed since the rate hikes.

We should not keep pushing rates higher right now. Instead, pull rates back slightly and enhance promotions to regain lease-up momentum.

Gross Potential Rent (GPR) increased ~7% from ~$117k to ~$126k after August rate hikes.

Physical occupancy stayed flat at ~52% (≈400 units), well below the 69% target for August.

Economic occupancy dropped from ~37% to ~34% – revenue potential is rising, but actual rent collected lags.

Move-ins slowed: strong in early August (16 move-ins, 80% conversion), but dropped mid-month (3 move-ins, 50% conversion).

Net occupancy growth: only +1 unit for the month as move-outs nearly matched move-ins.

Self Storage Solutions (3.5 mi) – Similar climate facility. Pricing ~$74 (5×5) and ~$110–120 (10×10). Occupancy likely ~80%. Runs promos.

Five Star Storage (multiple sites) – Lower-priced competitor. Rates ~$49 (5×5), $59 (5×10), ~$100–110 (10×10). Multiple units still available.

Other competitors – Dakota Self Storage, StoreMoor, etc., offer even lower rates ($60–70 for 5×10). StoreMoor advertises “1st full month free.”

Takeaway: Premiere is the highest-priced option in the market, especially for 10×10 and larger units. Competitors undercut rates by 10–30%.

Premiere offers 50% off 1st month (mostly on upper-floor units). Ground-floor units often full price.

Competitors use a mix of discounted base rates (Five Star) or similar first-month specials (Self Storage, StoreMoor).

Small units (5×5, 5×10) at Premiere are ~95% full – demand is strong, rates can hold.

Larger units (10×10+) are ~45–50% full – demand weaker, high rates slowing absorption.

Pause further rate hikes – occupancy has stalled at ~52% after increases.

Target discounts: Expand specials to larger units (10×10, 10×15, 10×20) to stimulate move-ins.

Hold or push rates slightly on smaller units (high demand, nearly full).

Focus on occupancy: Fill units first, then resume aggressive rate growth closer to stabilization (~80%+).

Monitor comps weekly – if Self Storage Solutions or Five Star raise prices as they fill, Premiere can follow.

After implementing rate increases in early August, Premiere Storage’s Gross Potential Rent (GPR) – the total rent if all units were rented at current standard rates – has risen sharply. GPR climbed from roughly $117k in the first week of August to about $126k by mid-August, an increase of ~7% in potential revenue. This reflects the higher posted rates across unit sizes. However, physical occupancy has remained flat or slightly declined: the facility held about 52–53% of units occupied throughout August. In unit terms, occupancy peaked around 404 units (52.6%) on Aug 8 and dipped to 400 units (52.1%) by Aug 20. Economic occupancy (actual rent collected vs. full potential) also fell from ~37% to ~34%, indicating that while potential rent grew, actual revenue has not yet caught up (due to vacancies and discounts). The chart below illustrates the divergence between rising GPR and flat occupancy:

Figure: Gross Potential Rent (blue, left axis) vs. Unit Occupancy % (green, right axis) at Premiere Storage Fargo, week-by-week in August 2025. GPR jumped after early August rate hikes, while occupancy hovered around ~52%.

⁠

Occupancy by square footage shows a similar trend – just under 49% of rentable square feet were occupied as of mid-August. In other words, half the facility’s space remains empty, so the rate increases have been applied while the property is still in lease-up phase.

Move-in velocity and lead volume have notably slowed following the rate hikes. In the first week of August (Aug 1–7), the facility generated ~20 new leads and converted 16 move-ins (an 80% conversion) as tenants rushed in ahead of or during the initial price changes. By the second week (Aug 8–15), only 6 additional leads came in, resulting in 3 move-ins (conversion ~50%, bringing MTD conversion down to 73%). This suggests demand fell as prices rose. By Aug 20, total move-ins for the month reached 22 (only ~3 more in the latter half of the month), roughly matching move-outs (21), for a net gain of just +1 unit occupied over the period. The slowdown in leasing activity is visualized below:

Figure: Weekly lead inquiries vs. move-ins at Premiere Storage Fargo in August 2025. After a strong first week (rate increases began), new customer inquiries and move-ins dropped sharply in subsequent weeks.

⁠

Rental rate yield: The average actual rent per occupied unit is well below the new standard rates, reflecting promotions and pro-rated move-ins. For example, a 10×10 climate unit on upper floors averages ~$112 actual rent vs. a $152 posted rate for ground-floor units

premierestorage.thestorageadvantage.com⁠

. This gap shows heavy discounting (e.g. 50% off first month on many units) and the impact of free month promotions on economic occupancy.

In summary, week-by-week since early August we see: GPR (potential revenue) increasing each week due to higher posted rates, but unit and square-foot occupancy stagnating ~50% or even dipping slightly. Move-in volumes have not kept pace with last month, resulting in flat occupancy. The early-August rent hike appears to have cooled demand, evidenced by fewer leads and a lower move-in conversion rate in mid-August.

Premiere Storage is competing in a price-sensitive local market. Within a 5-mile radius of 3740 51st Ave S (south Fargo), there are several other self-storage facilities – notably Self Storage Solutions (a large indoor climate facility) and multiple Five Star Storage locations – offering climate-controlled units at lower price points:

Self Storage Solutions – Fargo (3030 36th St S) – A similarly high-end, climate-controlled facility (~3.5 miles away). It advertises prices starting around $74/month for a 5′x5′ unit

selfstoragesolutionsnd.com⁠

, which undercuts Premiere’s $83–99 for 5×5. Likely rates for a 10×10 climate unit are around $110–$120/month, again slightly below Premiere’s $126–$152. This facility offers modern amenities (heated indoor loading bay, Bluetooth access) comparable to Premiere

selfstoragesolutionsnd.com⁠

⁠

selfstoragesolutionsnd.com⁠

, and it also runs promotions (its listed prices already reflect current discounts

selfstoragesolutionsnd.com⁠

). Self Storage Solutions is an established operation and appears to have healthy occupancy (not published, but fewer “1 left” warnings online), suggesting it’s further along in lease-up – potentially on the order of ~80% full (anecdotal estimate).

Five Star Storage – 3825 34th Ave S (Fargo) – A climate-controlled site ~4 miles away. Current street rates are $49/month for 5′x5′, $59 for 5′x10′, and $104 for 10′x10′

sparefoot.com⁠

. These rates are significantly lower than Premiere’s (e.g. 10×10 at Five Star is ~$100 vs. $126–$152 at Premiere). Five Star appears to be using lower base rates without explicit move-in specials – likely a strategy to fill units faster. Even at these prices, this location still shows multiple units available (e.g. “3 left” in some sizes)

sparefoot.com⁠

, implying it has not reached full occupancy either.

Five Star Storage – 3255 43rd St S (Fargo) – A newer Five Star facility (~4.5 miles away). Its climate unit rates are around $54 for 5′x5′ and $109 for 10′x10′

sparefoot.com⁠

. This is closer to Premiere’s range but still a notch lower. They also have several units open. Five Star’s other nearby locations (e.g. 3955 40th Ave S, 3241 32nd St S) show 10×10 prices from $89 up to ~$103

sparefoot.com⁠

⁠

sparefoot.com⁠

, all well below Premiere’s top rates. Many of these competitors offer 24-hour access and contactless rental like Premiere, though some are older facilities with fewer amenities (hence the lower price).

Other competitors: Dakota Self Storage Center (303 41st St S, ~2.8 miles) and StoreMoor Self Storage (Moorhead, ~3.7 miles) offer standard drive-up units at budget rates (e.g. 5×10 for ~$60)

sparefoot.com⁠

⁠

sparefoot.com⁠

, attracting the most price-sensitive customers. These are not climate-controlled, but they do exert pricing pressure on larger unit sizes for non-climate customers.

Promotional tactics in the market vary. Premiere is currently giving 50% off first month on all its upper-floor climate units (and no discount on ground-floor units)

premierestorage.thestorageadvantage.com⁠

⁠

premierestorage.thestorageadvantage.com⁠

. This dual-tier promo is evident in their website pricing (e.g. “$63 during promo, $126 after” for a 10×10 elevator-access unit)

premierestorage.thestorageadvantage.com⁠

. Competitors like Self Storage Solutions also appear to offer introductory discounts (their site indicates prices reflect promotions

selfstoragesolutionsnd.com⁠

, possibly similar half-off deals). Some Five Star locations instead simply price lower everyday rates and do not advertise move-in specials (no “first month free” noted on their listings), aiming to be the low-cost option. One exception is StoreMoor, which explicitly offers “1st full month free” on its listings

sparefoot.com⁠

– a clear attempt to draw budget-minded renters.

In terms of occupancy, most competitors have availability across unit sizes (as seen by SpareFoot listings showing multiple units open), indicating no facility is fully stabilized yet in this submarket. Self Storage Solutions, being a prominent facility, likely has the highest occupancy among them, but even it is still marketing units actively. Five Star’s multiple sites suggest the supply in South Fargo/West Fargo has expanded, giving renters ample choice. Notably, Premiere’s current occupied 400 units are only ~52% of its 768 units, whereas a mature facility would aim for 85–90%+. This underscores that Premiere’s aggressive rate strategy is occurring while significant vacancy remains, whereas competitors are generally keeping prices lower until they fill more units.

Given the data, Premiere Storage should consider pausing further rate increases and even moderating rates on the under-filled unit types until occupancy builds:

Occupancy vs. Price Trade-off: With only ~52% of units (≈49% of square footage) occupied, the facility is in lease-up. The early-August price hike, while boosting GPR, has nearly halted net occupancy growth. Move-in momentum dropped and economic occupancy fell, meaning much of the potential rent is unrealized. This is a strong signal that the new prices may be above what the local demand will bear at this stage. Competitors’ lower rates reinforce this – potential customers are likely price-shopping, and Premiere’s premium may be turning some away. Until Premiere reaches a higher physical occupancy (e.g. >70%), filling units should take priority over maximizing rate on each unit.

Competitive Positioning: Currently, Premiere is priced at the top of the market for climate-controlled storage in Fargo. For example, its 10×20 units at $221–265 are well above nearby Five Star’s ~$179–199 and likely above Self Storage Solutions’ range (estimated ~$180–200). While Premiere offers a state-of-the-art facility, these competitors also offer quality storage at noticeably lower prices. To prospective renters, Premiere’s value proposition may not justify the extra cost when so many alternatives exist nearby. It may be wise to hold rates steady (no further increases) or even introduce targeted discounts to stay competitive – for instance, offering a promo on the large units (10×15, 10×20) which have ~45% occupancy. This can stimulate move-ins for those sizes that are lagging.

Leasing Velocity: The lead and rental data show that demand exists – over 25 inquiries came in by mid-month – but conversion dropped when rates rose. By easing pricing (or enhancing promotions), Premiere can improve its conversion rate again. The first week of August showed that with the right incentive, a high percentage of leads will convert (80%+). Management should aim to restore that momentum by making offers that are competitive. For example, extending the 50%-off promotion to more unit types or offering it on ground-floor units for a limited time could attract hesitant customers who are shopping around.

Revenue Management Consideration: It’s notable that small units (5×5, 5×10) are nearly full at Premiere (over 95% occupied) even after the rate increase – indicating high demand and less price sensitivity in that segment. For these sizes, the facility can likely hold or continue modest rate increases (they are still competitively priced around market-average). However, for mid-size and large units (10×10 and up) where occupancy is 40–50%, the current pricing is aggressive relative to peers. Lowering the street rate or increasing the discount (e.g. move-in special from 50% to “first month free” for a limited time) on those could quickly improve lease-up without drastically undermining long-term rate integrity. The short-term revenue “loss” is outweighed by the benefit of filling units sooner and generating cash flow (currently, 350+ units are sitting vacant at $0 revenue).

Monitor Market and Adjust Dynamically: It’s advisable to continually monitor competitor rates/promotions. If, for instance, Self Storage Solutions fills up and raises its prices, Premiere can respond by tightening discounts. But in the current climate of ample availability, price leadership may be counterproductive – being the highest-priced option with the lowest occupancy is not a sustainable position. Instead, a strategy to “follow the market down” slightly – match or just modestly exceed the average market rates – until a critical mass of occupancy is achieved will likely yield better overall revenue. Once Premiere climbs closer to stabilization (say 80%+ occupied), and if demand in Fargo remains strong, then aggressive rate pushes can resume.

Conclusion: The data indicate that the recent rate hikes have outpaced demand at the current occupancy level. I recommend holding off on any further rate increases. In fact, selectively rolling back rates or enhancing promotions for under-occupied sizes (especially large units) for the next few weeks is prudent to regain leasing momentum. This more conservative approach should continue until occupancy improves and the facility is more in line with market occupancy levels. At that point, with fewer vacant units to sell, Premiere can cautiously push rates upward again. In short, focus on occupancy now – even at slightly lower rates – to build a tenant base, and revisit aggressive revenue management once the property is closer to stabilization. This balanced strategy will maximize long-term revenue by ensuring the facility doesn’t sacrifice move-ins (and market share) during its critical lease-up phase.

⁠

fargo compprice_2025-08-21.xlsx

11 KB

⁠

MovementSummary_PremiereStorage-Fargo_08.01.25-08.20.25.xlsx

7.6 KB

⁠

Occupancy_PremiereStorage-Fargo_08.20.25.xlsx

9.1 KB