Athena vs Redshift Spectrum

Service Type: Serverless, interactive query service.

Setup and Management: Completely serverless, no infrastructure to manage.

Performance Tuning: Automatic, with no need for manual tuning or cluster management.

Use Case:

Ideal for ad-hoc queries and quick insights on data stored in S3.

Best for scenarios where you need to run queries without maintaining a long-running data warehouse.

Integration: Integrates directly with AWS Glue Data Catalog for schema management.

Cost: Charged per query based on the amount of data scanned.

Scenarios:

Analyzing log files, CSV, JSON, Parquet, ORC files stored in S3.

Running interactive, ad-hoc SQL queries on S3 data without complex setup.

Service Type: Extension of Amazon Redshift.

Setup and Management: Requires an Amazon Redshift cluster; queries offload to S3 using the Redshift SQL engine.

Performance Tuning: Leverages Redshift's optimization features; requires some management of the Redshift cluster.

Use Case:

Ideal for complex queries that may combine structured data in Amazon Redshift with semi-structured data in S3.

Best for extending the storage of a Redshift data warehouse without moving the data.

Integration: Integrates with Redshift and uses Redshift’s SQL capabilities and optimization.

Cost: Charged based on the amount of data scanned in S3 plus the cost of maintaining the Redshift cluster.

Scenarios:

Running queries that join data in Amazon Redshift with data in S3.

Scaling out a Redshift data warehouse by offloading infrequently accessed data to S3 and querying it as needed.

Key Differences

Service Type:

Athena: Fully serverless query service.

Redshift Spectrum: Extension of Amazon Redshift for querying S3 data.

Management:

Athena: No infrastructure to manage, purely serverless.

Redshift Spectrum: Requires managing a Redshift cluster.

Performance Tuning:

Athena: Automatic performance tuning.

Redshift Spectrum: Utilizes Redshift’s optimization and may require manual tuning.

Use Case:

Athena: Ad-hoc querying and quick insights on S3 data.

Redshift Spectrum: Extending Redshift queries to include S3 data, suitable for integrating structured and semi-structured data.

Cost Model:

Athena: Pay per query based on data scanned.

Redshift Spectrum: Pay per data scanned in S3 plus Redshift cluster costs.

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.