Eleutheria

Explore

Research

Second Step

Buddhism: A Religion, Not Just a Philosophy

Second Step is a widely implemented Social Emotional Learning (SEL) program designed to help students develop essential social and emotional skills.

While the program aims to improve emotional intelligence, resilience, and overall well-being, it is important to critically examine its foundational principles. While on the surface it appears to arguably offer beneficial character skills, Buddhist philosophy is the foundational core of Second Step.

While this is not a criticism of Buddhism as a philosophy or religion, it is a fundamental issue when it comes to parental awareness and choice for their children about what ideologies are presented in a formal public school classroom setting.

Second Step Website

⁠

Loading www.secondstep.org⁠

⁠

Load content from www.youtube.com? Loading external content may reveal information to 3rd parties. Learn more Allow⁠

⁠

Loading www.youtube.com⁠

Loading rumble.com⁠

⁠

Loading www.youtube.com⁠

Loading www.facebook.com⁠

Loading www.youtube.com⁠

Loading www.buddhistinquiry.org⁠

Loading www.youtube.com⁠

⁠

Foundational Principles of Second Step

Mindfulness in SEL

Mindfulness, a central component of the Second Step curriculum, is derived from Buddhist meditation practices. It involves focusing one's attention on the present moment, cultivating a non-judgmental awareness of thoughts, emotions, and sensations. In the context of SEL, mindfulness practices are used to help students manage stress, improve focus, and develop emotional regulation.

Key Mindfulness Practices in Second Step:

Mindful Breathing: Teaching students to focus on their breath to calm their minds and bodies.

Body Scans: Guiding students to pay attention to different parts of their bodies to increase bodily awareness.

Meditation: Encouraging periods of quiet reflection to help students become more aware of their thoughts and emotions.

The Name "Second Step"

The name "Second Step" itself has connotations related to Buddhist teachings. In Buddhism, the Eightfold Path is a central doctrine that outlines the steps towards achieving enlightenment. The second step of this path is "Right Intention," which involves committing oneself to ethical and mental self-improvement. By naming the program "Second Step," there is an implicit connection to this Buddhist tenet, which underscores the influence of Buddhist philosophy on the curriculum.

Analysis of the Foundational Principles

Not a Criticism of Buddhism

It is important to clarify that this analysis is not a criticism of Buddhism as a philosophy or a religion. Buddhism has provided valuable insights and practices that have benefited many individuals globally. The concern here is the appropriateness of incorporating religious principles into a public school curriculum.

Deep Integration of Buddhist Philosophy

The mindfulness practices promoted in Second Step are deeply ingrained in Buddhist philosophy. While these practices are presented as secular methods for improving emotional well-being, their origins in Buddhist meditation cannot be overlooked. This integration of religiously rooted practices into a public education program raises significant constitutional questions.

Argument Against the Use of Second Step in Public Schools

Violation of the Establishment Clause

The Establishment Clause of the 1st Amendment prohibits the government from making any law “respecting an establishment of religion.” This means that public schools, as government entities, must remain neutral regarding religion and cannot promote or endorse religious practices.

Key Points of Concern:

Religious Origins of Mindfulness: The mindfulness practices integral to Second Step are rooted in Buddhism. By incorporating these practices into the curriculum, public schools may be seen as endorsing a particular religious perspective.

Implicit Religious Promotion: The connection between the name "Second Step" and the Buddhist doctrine of the Eightfold Path suggests an implicit promotion of Buddhist principles, further blurring the lines between secular education and religious practice.

Parental Rights and Religious Freedom: Parents who wish to raise their children according to their own religious beliefs may find that the incorporation of Buddhist-based mindfulness practices into the curriculum infringes upon their religious freedoms and parental rights.

Conclusion

Second Step's foundational principles, particularly its incorporation of mindfulness practices rooted in Buddhist philosophy, present a significant concern for public schools. While the goal of improving students' social and emotional well-being is commendable, it is essential to ensure that such programs do not violate the constitutional requirement of religious neutrality in public education. The integration of these practices may be seen as an endorsement of Buddhism, thus potentially violating the Establishment Clause of the 1st Amendment.

Call to Action

It is crucial for parents, educators, and community leaders to engage in open dialogue about the philosophical underpinnings of educational programs like Second Step.

By raising awareness and seeking alternatives that respect the diverse religious beliefs of all students, we can ensure that public education remains inclusive and constitutionally compliant.

Together, we can advocate for educational practices that support the well-being of students without compromising religious freedoms and constitutional principles.

For more information, resources, and ways to get involved, explore the rest of our site and stay connected with the Eleutheria Project.

⁠

Sign the Petition

⁠

Eaton Community School Board Must Uphold the 1st Amendment - Online petition In recent months, the Eaton Community School District (ECSD) has found itself at the center of a significant controversy involving the infringement of First Amendment rights, particularly those pertaining to religious freedom under both the establishment and free exercise clauses. The actions taken by the school district have not only caused emotional distress but have also infringed upon the fundamental rights of parents to direct the religious upbringing of their children. This situation has p www.openpetition.org⁠

⁠

Together, we can make a difference.

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.