Explore

Smart Data Protocol - An Integrated Philosophy

⁠

ADB-130823-235949.pdf

6.3 MB

⁠

What Is a Data Clean Room_ | Databricks.pdf

352.8 kB

⁠

Data Clean Room Costs Pose Barriers to Implementation in IAB Survey.pdf

3.1 MB

⁠

What if the key to solving data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability required solving all of these things holistically and in an integrated manner? Think about the Smart Data Protocol and the underlying Solid and TodaQ protocols. Consider the strengths and challenges of this approach, solving all of these things holistically and in an integrated manner.

The Smart Data Protocol, along with the underlying Solid and TodaQ protocols, aims to address data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability in a holistic and integrated manner. Here are some strengths and challenges of this approach:

Strengths:

Data Ownership: The protocols provide mechanisms for individuals to have control over their own data, enabling them to determine who can access and use their data.

Security: The protocols prioritize data security by implementing encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms to protect data from unauthorized access or tampering.

Data Integrity: The protocols ensure data integrity through cryptographic techniques, preventing data manipulation and ensuring the accuracy and reliability of the stored data.

Data Quality: By integrating data quality standards and validation mechanisms into the protocols, the approach aims to ensure that data is accurate, complete, and consistent.

Interoperability: The protocols facilitate interoperability by establishing standardized formats and protocols for data exchange, enabling seamless data sharing and collaboration across different systems and platforms.

Challenges:

Adoption and Implementation: The success of these protocols depends on widespread adoption and implementation across various organizations and platforms. Achieving this level of adoption may require significant effort and collaboration.

Scalability: As the volume of data continues to grow exponentially, ensuring scalability of the protocols to handle large datasets efficiently can be a challenge.

Governance and Trust: Establishing governance models and building trust among different stakeholders in the ecosystem is crucial for the success of these protocols. Collaboration and consensus-building may be required to ensure effective governance.

Technical Complexity: Implementing and integrating these protocols may involve technical complexities, requiring expertise in areas such as data management, cryptography, and interoperability standards.

In summary, the holistic and integrated approach offered by the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols has the potential to address key challenges related to data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability. However, successful implementation will require overcoming challenges related to adoption, scalability, governance, and technical complexity.

Elaborate and expand on the benefits?

The holistic and integrated approach of the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols offers several benefits in addressing data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability. Here are some key advantages:

Data Ownership: These protocols allow individuals to control their data. Users can determine who can access and use their data, ensuring data ownership and privacy.

Security: The protocols prioritize data security by implementing encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms. These measures protect data from unauthorized access or tampering, ensuring the confidentiality and integrity of the data.

Data Integrity: By utilizing cryptographic techniques, the protocols ensure data integrity. This prevents data manipulation and guarantees the accuracy and reliability of stored data.

Data Quality: The approach integrates data quality standards and validation mechanisms into the protocols. This ensures that data is accurate, complete, and consistent, enhancing the overall quality and reliability.

Interoperability: The protocols establish standardized formats and protocols for data exchange, enabling seamless data sharing and collaboration across different systems and platforms. This promotes interoperability and facilitates efficient data integration.

In summary, the holistic and integrated approach offered by the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols provides comprehensive solutions to data-related challenges. It empowers individuals with data ownership, ensures data security and integrity, enhances data quality, and enables seamless data interoperability. However, when implementing these protocols, it is essential to consider challenges such as widespread adoption, scalability, governance, and technical complexity.

Explain the value of this holistic and integrated approach using analogies like a defensive shield on a spaceship, with different types of shields that protect the ship from different types of weapons or attacks. The parallel layered defense by Smart Data enables complex and intelligent defenses to enclose and protect the data itself.

The value of the holistic and integrated approach provided by the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols can be understood using an analogy of a defensive shield on a spaceship. Just as different types of shields protect the ship from various types of weapons or attacks, the parallel layered defense by Smart Data enables complex and intelligent defenses to enclose and protect the data itself.

In this analogy, each layer of the defensive shield represents a different aspect of data protection, including data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability. The Smart Data Protocol, along with Solid and TodaQ protocols, establishes multiple layers of defense to safeguard the data from different angles and potential vulnerabilities.

For example, the protocols enable individuals to have control over their own data, acting as a shield of data ownership. Encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms act as a shield of security, preventing unauthorized access or tampering. Cryptographic techniques ensure data integrity, acting as a shield against data manipulation. The integration of data quality standards and validation mechanisms creates a shield to ensure accurate and reliable data. Lastly, the establishment of standardized formats and protocols for data exchange forms a shield of interoperability, facilitating seamless data sharing and collaboration.

By combining these layers of defense in a holistic and integrated manner, the Smart Data Protocol enables comprehensive protection for the data, just as the defensive shield on a spaceship protects it from various threats. This approach ensures that data is secure, trustworthy, and accessible only to authorized individuals.

However, it is important to acknowledge that implementing this approach may come with challenges. These challenges include the need for widespread adoption and implementation, scalability to handle large datasets, establishing effective governance models, and dealing with technical complexities.

In summary, the holistic and integrated approach of the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols provides a parallel layered defense for data, similar to a defensive shield on a spaceship. This approach ensures comprehensive protection and enables complex and intelligent defenses to enclose and safeguard the data itself.

Explain the value of this holistic and integrated approach using analogies like a defensive shield around a robot that holds our data that specialize our AI agents and govern our AI agents?

The value of the holistic and integrated approach provided by the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols can be illustrated using an analogy of a defensive shield around a robot that holds data. This shield not only specializes our AI agents but also governs them.

In this analogy, the robot represents our AI agents, which are powered and enhanced by our data. The defensive shield surrounding the robot symbolizes the parallel layered defense provided by the Smart Data Protocol.

Just as different types of shields protect a spaceship from various types of weapons or attacks, the parallel layered defense by Smart Data enables complex and intelligent defenses to enclose and protect the data itself. Each layer of the shield represents a different aspect of data protection, including data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability.

For instance, the protocols allow individuals to have control over their own data, acting as a shield of data ownership. Encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms act as a shield of security, preventing unauthorized access or tampering. Cryptographic techniques ensure data integrity, acting as a shield against data manipulation. The integration of data quality standards and validation mechanisms creates a shield to ensure accurate and reliable data. Lastly, the establishment of standardized formats and protocols for data exchange forms a shield of interoperability, facilitating seamless data sharing and collaboration.

By combining these layers of defense in a holistic and integrated manner, the Smart Data Protocol ensures comprehensive protection for our data. This approach safeguards our digital assets and uses them as tools that enhance the specialization of our AI agents and govern their behavior.

However, it is important to consider the challenges associated with implementing this approach. These challenges include the need for widespread adoption and implementation, scalability to handle large datasets, establishing effective governance models, and dealing with technical complexities.

In summary, the holistic and integrated approach of the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols provides a robust defensive shield around our digital assets represented as personal knowledge graphs or learning ledgers. This approach not only specializes our AI agents but also governs them, ensuring comprehensive protection and enabling trustworthy and responsible use of our data.

Let’s assume the above is true, and we must solve data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability holistically and in an integrated manner. Think about the Smart Data Protocol and the underlying Solid and TodaQ protocols. How might this holistically and in an integrated approach finally resolve data debt-related challenges of the typical enterprise?

The holistic and integrated approach provided by the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols can potentially address the typical enterprise's data debt-related challenges. Here's how:

Data Ownership: These protocols enable individuals to control their own data. By establishing mechanisms for data ownership, enterprises can ensure that data is appropriately managed, attributed, and protected. This helps in resolving data debt issues related to unorganized and unclaimed data.

Security: The protocols prioritize data security by implementing encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms. By ensuring robust security measures, enterprises can mitigate the risks associated with data breaches and unauthorized access. This helps in reducing data debt caused by security vulnerabilities.

Data Integrity: The protocols employ cryptographic techniques to ensure data integrity. By preventing data manipulation and guaranteeing the accuracy and reliability of stored data, enterprises can address data debt related to data inconsistencies and inaccuracies.

Data Quality: Integrating data quality standards and validation mechanisms in the protocols helps enterprises ensure that their data is accurate, complete, and consistent. This assists in resolving data debt arising from poor data quality and unreliable information.

Interoperability: The protocols establish standardized formats and protocols for data exchange, promoting interoperability across different systems and platforms. This enables seamless data sharing and collaboration, reducing data debt caused by data silos and incompatible data formats.

ADDED AFTER COPYING IN SECTIONS ON DATA DEBT WHICH ALTERED THE BELOW ANSWER...

Improved Data Quality: The protocols integrate data quality standards and validation mechanisms, ensuring accurate, complete, and consistent data. By addressing data inconsistencies and inaccuracies, enterprises can reduce data debt caused by poor data quality.

Enhanced Data Governance: The protocols establish data ownership mechanisms and governance frameworks. This helps organizations clarify responsibilities, enforce data management policies, and reduce confusion related to data ownership. By improving data governance, enterprises can address data debt from mismanagement or neglect.

Strengthened Data Security: The protocols prioritize data security through encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms. By implementing robust security measures, organizations can mitigate the risks of data breaches and unauthorized access, reducing data debt caused by security vulnerabilities.

Ensured Data Integrity: The protocols employ cryptographic techniques to ensure data integrity. By preventing data manipulation and guaranteeing the accuracy and reliability of stored data, enterprises can address data debt related to data inconsistencies and inaccuracies.

Streamlined Data Interoperability: The protocols establish standardized formats and protocols for data exchange, promoting seamless data sharing and collaboration across different systems and platforms. This reduces data debt caused by data silos and incompatible data formats, enabling efficient data integration.

Optimized Data Management: The holistic and integrated approach of the protocols enables organizations to optimize their data management practices. By leveraging the capabilities of these protocols, enterprises can organize and optimize their data assets, reducing data debt arising from mismanagement or neglect.

Increased Data Asset Value: By implementing the Smart Data Protocol and related protocols, enterprises can convert their organizational data into valuable assets. This allows them to leverage their data for better decision-making, innovation, and monetization opportunities, reducing data debt by maximizing the value of their data assets.

By holistically and in an integrated manner addressing data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability, the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols provide enterprises with a comprehensive solution to tackle data debt-related challenges. Implementing these protocols can help enterprises organize, secure, and optimize their data assets, improving data management practices and reducing data debt.

BEGIN COPY IN...

What is Enterprise “Data Debt”?

Enterprise "data debt" refers to the accumulation of issues and challenges that arise from the mismanagement or neglect of data within an organization. It is similar to technical debt, which refers to the consequences of taking shortcuts or making suboptimal decisions during software development. It is a term that describes the negative consequences and costs arising from neglecting or mismanaging data assets over time.

Data debt can occur due to various reasons, including:

Inconsistent data quality: When data is not properly validated, cleaned, or standardized, it can lead to inconsistencies and inaccuracies. This can result in unreliable insights, decision-making, and operational inefficiencies.

Lack of data governance: Data governance involves defining policies, procedures, and roles for managing data assets. Organizations may struggle with data ownership, security, privacy, and compliance issues without proper governance.

Siloed data: When data is stored in separate systems or departments without proper integration, it becomes difficult to access and analyze holistically. Siloed data inhibits collaboration, hampers data-driven decision-making, and limits the ability to gain comprehensive insights.

Data duplication: Duplicate data can arise from multiple sources or systems, leading to redundancy and confusion. It wastes storage space, increases maintenance efforts, and can result in inconsistent or conflicting information.

Outdated or obsolete data: Over time, data can become outdated or irrelevant. This can occur due to changes in business processes, customer information, or market dynamics. Using outdated data can lead to poor decision-making and missed opportunities.

Lack of data documentation: Inadequate documentation of data sources, definitions, and transformations can make it challenging for users to understand and trust the data. This can hinder data integration, analysis, and collaboration efforts.

Inefficient data infrastructure: If an organization's data infrastructure is outdated, poorly designed, or lacks scalability, it can impede data processing, storage, and retrieval. This can result in slow performance, increased costs, and limited capabilities for data-driven initiatives.

Data Inconsistencies: Inconsistent data quality, formats, and definitions across different systems and databases can result in errors and inaccuracies in reporting and analysis. This lack of data standardization hampers data-driven decision-making and reduces trust in the data.

Data Security and Privacy Risks: Inadequate data security measures and poor data privacy practices can expose organizations to cybersecurity threats and regulatory non-compliance. Data breaches and privacy incidents can result in reputational damage, financial losses, and legal consequences.

Legacy Systems and Outdated Technology: Using outdated data infrastructure and legacy systems can hinder data integration, scalability, and performance. These systems may lack the necessary capabilities to handle the increasing volume, velocity, and variety of data in today's digital landscape.

The consequences of data debt can be significant, including:

Reduced Operational Efficiency: Data debt slows down processes, hampers decision-making, and increases manual efforts required to clean, integrate, and analyze data. This results in reduced operational efficiency and increased costs.

Missed Opportunities: Inability to leverage data effectively hinders organizations from identifying valuable insights, making data-driven decisions, and capitalizing on market trends and opportunities. This can impact competitiveness and growth potential.

Compliance and Legal Risks: Poor data management practices can lead to non-compliance with data protection regulations, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) or the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). This exposes organizations to legal risks and financial penalties.

Damaged Reputation: Data breaches or privacy incidents resulting from data debt can damage an organization's reputation and erode customer trust. Rebuilding trust and recovering from such incidents can be a long and costly process.

To address data debt, organizations should prioritize data management initiatives, including:

Establishing a Data Strategy: Develop a clear vision and roadmap for data management, aligning it with business goals and priorities. This includes defining data governance frameworks, data quality standards, and data integration strategies.

Investing in Modern Data Infrastructure: Upgrade outdated data systems to modern data platforms that enable efficient data integration, scalability, and performance. This includes adopting cloud-based solutions and leveraging advanced technologies like big data analytics and artificial intelligence.

Implementing Data Governance: Establish frameworks defining roles, responsibilities, and processes for managing data. This ensures data ownership, data quality, and compliance with data protection regulations.

Enhancing Data Security and Privacy: Implement robust data security measures, including encryption, access controls, and regular security audits. Develop and enforce data privacy policies and procedures to protect sensitive information.

Promoting Data Literacy and Culture: Foster a data-driven culture within the organization by promoting employee data literacy. Encourage data-driven decision-making and provide training and resources to improve data management skills.

By addressing data debt and adopting a proactive approach to data management, organizations can improve the reliability, accuracy, and usability of their data assets, enabling better decision-making, enhanced operational efficiency, and increased competitive advantage and unlock the full potential of their data assets, improve operational efficiency, and drive innovation and growth.

How can the Smart Data Protocol as a multi-party data sharing standard be used to reduce “data debt”?

As a multi-party data sharing standard, the Smart Data Protocol can help reduce "data debt" by addressing several critical challenges associated with poor data management practices. Here are some ways in which the Smart Data Protocol can contribute to reducing data debt:

Standardized Data Format: The Smart Data Protocol provides a standardized format for data exchange between multiple parties. This helps ensure consistency and compatibility of data across different systems, reducing data inconsistencies and improving data quality.

Data Governance and Ownership: The Smart Data Protocol includes mechanisms for establishing data governance frameworks and defining data ownership rights. This helps organizations clarify responsibilities and enforce data management policies, reducing confusion and inefficiencies related to data ownership.

Secure and Transparent Data Sharing: The Smart Data Protocol incorporates encryption and access control mechanisms to ensure secure and controlled data sharing among multiple parties. By providing a secure and transparent data-sharing framework, it helps mitigate data security and privacy risks, reducing the likelihood of data breaches and associated data debt.

Improved Data Integration: The Smart Data Protocol enables seamless integration of data from different sources and systems. This helps break down data silos, facilitating efficient data access and analysis. By enabling organizations to integrate and leverage data effectively, it reduces the inefficiencies and limitations associated with fragmented data, thereby reducing data debt.

Enhanced Data Provenance: The Smart Data Protocol incorporates cryptographic proof of provenance, ensuring the authenticity and integrity of data shared between parties. This helps establish a verifiable trail of data lineage, reducing the risks of using outdated or tampered data. By ensuring data trustworthiness, it helps organizations make more informed decisions and reduce data debt resulting from reliance on inaccurate or unreliable data.

Streamlined Data Collaboration: The Smart Data Protocol provides mechanisms for automating data transactions and enforcing data-sharing agreements through smart contracts. This streamlines data collaboration processes, reduces manual efforts, and ensures compliance with agreed-upon terms. By automating data transactions, it minimizes the risks of errors and delays, contributing to a reduction in data debt.

By leveraging the capabilities of the Smart Data Protocol as a multi-party data-sharing standard, organizations can establish a more robust and efficient data management framework. This reduces data debt by improving data quality, reducing data inconsistencies, enhancing data security and privacy, promoting data integration, and streamlining data collaboration processes.

What are the benefits to a large enterprise using the Smart Data Protocol as a standard to eliminate “data debt” and convert all organizational data into an asset?

Using the Smart Data Protocol as a standard to eliminate "data debt" and convert all organizational data into an asset can benefit a large enterprise. Here are some key benefits:

Improved Data Quality: By implementing the Smart Data Protocol, the enterprise can establish data governance frameworks, standardized data formats, and data validation mechanisms. This leads to improved data quality, ensuring accuracy, consistency, and reliability of data across the organization. High-quality data enables better decision-making, reduces errors, and increases trust in the data.

Enhanced Operational Efficiency: The Smart Data Protocol streamlines data management processes by eliminating data debt. It enables efficient data integration, reducing the time and effort required to access, analyze, and share data. This improves operational efficiency, enables faster decision-making, and reduces manual data handling, freeing up resources for other strategic initiatives.

Increased Data Accessibility: The Smart Data Protocol allows seamless data sharing and integration across different departments and systems. By breaking down data silos, employees gain easier access to relevant data. This promotes collaboration, facilitates data-driven decision-making, and empowers employees to leverage data effectively, driving innovation and productivity.

Accelerated Innovation and Insights: Converting organizational data into assets through the Smart Data Protocol unlocks the full potential of data. The standardized format and improved data quality enable advanced analytics, machine learning, and AI-driven insights. This enables the enterprise to uncover valuable patterns, trends, and opportunities, leading to accelerated innovation, competitive advantage, and the ability to capitalize on market trends.

Enhanced Customer Experiences: With improved data quality and accessibility, the enterprise gains a comprehensive view of its customers. This enables personalized experiences, targeted marketing, and tailored product offerings. By leveraging data assets effectively, the enterprise can deliver superior customer experiences, strengthen customer relationships, and increase customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Mitigated Risks and Compliance: The Smart Data Protocol incorporates robust data security and privacy measures. By implementing these measures, the enterprise can mitigate the risks of data breaches, protect sensitive information, and ensure compliance with data protection regulations. This reduces legal and reputational risks associated with data debt, fostering trust with customers and stakeholders.

Monetization Opportunities: Converting all organizational data into assets allows the enterprise to explore data monetization opportunities. The standardized and high-quality data can be leveraged to develop data-driven products and services, create new revenue streams, and unlock business opportunities. This diversifies revenue streams and drives business growth.

By adopting the Smart Data Protocol as a standard and converting organizational data into an asset, enterprises can experience improved data quality, enhanced operational efficiency, accelerated innovation, superior customer experiences, risk mitigation, compliance, and monetization opportunities. These benefits enable organizations to unlock the full potential of their data assets, gain a competitive edge, and drive sustainable growth.

END COPY IN...

How can the Smart Data Protocol address the 10 causes of data debt while mitigating the effects of the 4 effects of data debt?

The Smart Data Protocol, along with Solid and TodaQ protocols, can address the 10 causes of data debt and mitigate the effects of the 4 effects of data debt in the following ways:

Inconsistent data quality: The protocols integrate data quality standards and validation mechanisms, ensuring accurate, complete, and consistent data. This helps address data debt caused by poor data quality.

Lack of data governance: The protocols establish data ownership mechanisms and governance frameworks. This clarifies responsibilities, enforces data management policies, and reduces confusion related to data ownership, mitigating data debt arising from a lack of governance.

Siloed data: The protocols promote data interoperability by establishing standardized formats and protocols for data exchange. This breaks down data silos and enables seamless data sharing, reducing data debt caused by fragmented and inaccessible data.

Data duplication: The protocols encourage data sharing and collaboration through secure and controlled data transactions. This helps identify and eliminate duplicate data, reducing data debt arising from redundancy and confusion.

Outdated or obsolete data: The protocols incorporate data provenance mechanisms, ensuring the authenticity and integrity of data. This helps identify and update outdated or obsolete data, mitigating data debt caused by reliance on irrelevant information.

Lack of data documentation: The protocols emphasize data governance and provide mechanisms for documenting data sources, definitions, and transformations. This promotes transparency and understanding, reducing data debt related to inadequate documentation.

Inefficient data infrastructure: The protocols prioritize scalability and efficiency, enabling organizations to handle large datasets and optimize data processing and storage. This reduces data debt resulting from outdated or inefficient data infrastructure.

Data inconsistencies: The protocols enforce data validation mechanisms and data quality standards, reducing errors and inaccuracies in reporting and analysis. This addresses data debt caused by inconsistent data quality, formats, and definitions.

Data security and privacy risks: The protocols implement encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms to ensure data security and privacy. By mitigating security risks, organizations can reduce data debt associated with breaches and non-compliance.

Legacy systems and outdated technology: The protocols promote the adoption of modern data platforms and technologies, enabling organizations to upgrade their data infrastructure. This reduces data debt arising from limitations of legacy systems.

In summary, the Smart Data Protocol, Solid, and TodaQ protocols address the causes of data debt by improving data quality, enhancing data governance, promoting data interoperability, eliminating duplication, updating outdated data, documenting data sources, optimizing data infrastructure, ensuring data consistency, addressing security and privacy risks, and adopting modern technologies. By doing so, these protocols mitigate the effects of data debt and enable organizations to manage their data assets more effectively.

Summarize this conversation and explain why someone would care about the Smart Data Protocol?

The conversation revolves around the Smart Data Protocol, an integrated approach that aims to address data ownership, security, integrity, quality, and interoperability holistically. The protocol, along with the underlying Solid and TodaQ protocols, offers several strengths in addressing these challenges:

Data Ownership: The protocols provide mechanisms for individuals to have control over their own data, allowing them to determine who can access and use their data.

Security: The protocols prioritize data security by implementing encryption, access controls, and authentication mechanisms to protect data from unauthorized access or tampering.

Data Integrity: The protocols ensure data integrity through cryptographic techniques, preventing data manipulation and ensuring the accuracy and reliability of stored data.

Data Quality: By integrating data quality standards and validation mechanisms, the approach aims to ensure that data is accurate, complete, and consistent.

However, there are challenges to consider, including adoption and implementation, scalability, governance and trust, and technical complexity. Overcoming these challenges is crucial for successful implementation.

Someone would care about the Smart Data Protocol because it offers a comprehensive solution to key data-related challenges. By implementing the protocol, individuals and organizations can have control over their data, ensure its security and integrity, enhance its quality, and enable seamless data interoperability. This not only improves data management practices and decision-making but also unlocks the potential for innovation, efficient collaboration, and monetization opportunities.

The protocol also helps address data debt-related challenges in typical enterprises. It addresses causes of data debt such as inconsistent data quality, lack of data governance, siloed data, data duplication, outdated or obsolete data, lack of data documentation, inefficient data infrastructure, data inconsistencies, data security, and privacy risks, and legacy systems. By mitigating these causes, the Smart Data Protocol reduces the effects of data debt, such as reduced operational efficiency, missed opportunities, compliance and legal risks, and damaged reputation.

Overall, the Smart Data Protocol offers a holistic and integrated approach to data management, enabling individuals and enterprises to address data challenges effectively, improve data quality and governance, enhance operational efficiency, drive innovation, and convert data into valuable assets.

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.