Skip to content
Alabama’s prison system is failing at its most basic responsibility: keeping people safe.Taxpayer money is being wasted defending abusive officers instead of fixing a broken system.Families deserve transparency and accountability from the Department of Corrections.Oversight is not optional; it’s a moral and civic necessity.Protecting the men who spoke out in this film is about defending Alabama’s values of honesty and fairness.
Thank attendees and remind them that this is a safe, respectful space for dialogue.Acknowledge that the film is heavy; it contains difficult truths and lived trauma.What moments in the film struck you most powerfully?How does seeing firsthand footage change your understanding of prison conditions compared to reading articles or seeing a story on the evening news?What role should Alabama’s faith communities, families, and local leaders play in demanding reform?How do you think the state’s $900 million plan for mega-prisons connects—or fails to connect—to what you just saw?If challenged on “criminals deserving punishment”: Re-center on humanity and constitutional rights (Eighth Amendment).“Serving time is the punishment. What the Constitution promises is that people won’t be tortured or left to die once they’re inside.”“The Eighth Amendment is clear: no cruel or unusual punishment. No one’s sentence includes being raped, beaten, denied medical care, or murdered.”“Alabama families expect accountability. Abuse and neglect don’t make anyone safer— they just destroy lives and waste taxpayer money.”If questions focus on federal vs. state roles: Emphasize Gov. Kay Ivey’s “Alabama solution” stance—and the need for local accountability plus federal oversight.“Governor Ivey has said Alabama will solve its own prison crisis. But years have passed, and the violence and deaths have only grown.”“Local leaders have a responsibility to fix this, but the federal government has a duty to step in when constitutional rights are being violated.”“This isn’t about politics—it’s about whether Alabama families can trust their state to keep people alive and use tax dollars responsibly.”If asked “what can I do?” → Point directly to the Calls to Action section below.
The Alabama prison crisis is a live case study in constitutional law, human rights, and public accountability.Students need to see how systemic injustice intersects with race, class, and geography in their own state and across the U.S.This film uses first-person documentation. It’s lived testimony, and that makes it a unique and vital educational tool.Our role as educators is to help students analyze complex realities with rigor and care, equipping them to ask: Who holds power? Who is harmed? Who builds power as a response to injustice, and why? Who is accountable?Discussing these issues openly helps young people prepare to be leaders who value justice, truth, and human dignity.
What did you learn from this film that you hadn’t seen in news reports or textbooks?How does firsthand footage change the way you understand prison conditions compared to official statements or media headlines?What parallels can you draw between the prison crisis and other civil or human rights struggles?What responsibility do young people, students, or educators have in responding to injustice that is happening in their own state or country?How should public money be spent if the goal is true public safety?Reframe to civics: “The law sets limits on punishment. The Constitution guarantees protection against cruel and unusual punishment. That is a civic principle, not an opinion.”Connect to civic education: “You are the generation that will vote, lead, and shape public policy. Understanding this crisis is part of your role as future citizens.”Encourage students to connect this issue to their coursework, write reflections or op-eds, or share resources with family and peers.For college students, emphasize civic engagement: contacting representatives, joining campus organizations, or participating in campaigns for justice.
As people of faith, we believe no life is disposable. The abuse and deaths inside Alabama’s prisons dishonor the God-given dignity of every human being.Alabama and other states spend millions defending abusive practices instead of building communities of safety and care. That is a misuse of resources entrusted to us.Protecting the men risking retaliation to tell the truth is not only a civic duty, but a sacred obligation.Families of people who are incarcerated are part of our congregations. When they suffer in silence, the whole body suffers.Oversight and accountability are not political demands; they are moral imperatives rooted in honesty, stewardship, and justice.Faith leaders must help our communities choose a path that values life, truth, and restoration over secrecy, profit, and neglect.
What does your faith tradition teach about the value of human dignity in times of suffering?How do these stories challenge us to think about mercy, justice, and accountability in Alabama today?What role should congregations play in supporting families of people who are incarcerated?Alabama is investing nearly $1 billion in new prisons. How does that align—or fail to align—with our moral responsibility to pursue restoration and redemption?In what ways can our communities of faith move from lament to action?“Punishment is not permission for cruelty. Our calling is to honor the dignity of every soul, even when accountability is necessary.”“Scripture is clear that justice must be tempered with mercy. No sentence includes being tortured, neglected, or left to die.”“Faith leaders have historically spoken against injustice—from civil rights to child labor. This is another such moment.”“Our congregations include the families of incarcerated people. To stand with them is to live out our faith.”“Our voices are stronger together. By signing on and speaking publicly, clergy can model courage and call our leaders to moral accountability.”
No parent should have to bury their child because the state failed to keep them alive in custody.Families are the backbone of our communities. When prisons destroy lives, they leave children without parents and parents without children.Teaching our kids about justice means holding leaders accountable when they break trust.Alabama is spending nearly a billion dollars on new prisons while schools and communities go without. Parents should be asking: is this the legacy we want for our children?Protecting whistleblowers and incarcerated people who spoke out in this film is about protecting the values we hope to pass down to the next generation.
What moments in the film reminded you most of your own role as a parent or caregiver?How do you think children are affected when parents are taken away or harmed in prison?What values do we want our kids to learn when they ask about justice, fairness, or government responsibility?What would it mean for Alabama’s children if state resources went into schools, healthcare, and prevention instead of prisons?Reframe to parenting values: “We discipline to teach and protect—not to abuse or destroy. The same should be true for our state.”“Because it’s our families who bear the consequences—children growing up without fathers, mothers grieving sons, communities destabilized.”Parents can speak to legislators, share their concerns with other families, attend community events, and model to their children what it looks like to stand up for dignity and justice.
On a team, everyone has value. No one is disposable. That’s the same standard we should expect from our state, whether it’s Alabama or anywhere else.The abuse shown in this film is destruction, not discipline. Coaches know the difference.Many of the men in these prisons grew up playing sports, sitting in our classrooms, living in our neighborhoods. They are part of our community’s story.Parents entrust their kids to us to teach them discipline, teamwork, and respect. When the state betrays those same values, we cannot stay silent.True strength comes from accountability, not from covering up violence or neglect.
What moments in the film reminded you of the difference between tough discipline and outright abuse?How does this connect to what we expect from leaders—whether on a team, in a school, or in government?If teamwork means having each other’s back, what responsibility do we have to the men risking their lives to tell the truth in this film?What lessons do you think young athletes should take from these stories about justice, fairness, and accountability?How would investing in schools, gyms, and community programs instead of prisons change the future of Alabama athletes and families?Reframe through sports values: “Breaking a rule gets you benched or disciplined. It doesn’t give a coach—or a state—the right to destroy you.”“Because these are our kids, our players, our neighbors. What happens in prison affects the same families who trust us with their sons on the field.”Encourage teams, booster clubs, and athletic associations to stand with families, speak publicly, and model accountability for young people.Highlight the importance of showing athletes that justice means protecting dignity—on the court, on the field, and in life.
Discussion Guide
The guides provide tailored messaging, discussion prompts, and facilitation tips for different audiences. Use the guide below that best fits your audience.
Calls to Action
1. Support the men featured in The Alabama Solution who blew the whistle on the AL Dept. of Corrections.
The Blow Your Whistle fundraising initiative is organized by friends of Melvin Ray, Ricardo (Raoul) Poole, and Kinetik Justice (Robert Earl Council), who were featured in the Academy Award-nominated documentary The Alabama Solution.
2. Call Kilby Correctional Facility and demand the safety of Robert Earl “Kinetik” Council.
We urge the public, media, and officials to contact Kilby at (334) 215-6600 to demand that they confirm their intention to maintain the safety of Mr. Council, and to ensure that he and others are not retaliated against.
3. Sign onto our open letter for safety and accountability in Alabama’s prisons.
Join fellow Alabamians in calling on Alabama’s elected officials and our Department of Corrections to increase transparency and accountability, and to ensure constitutional protections for incarcerated Alabamians.
Alabama Audiences
Key Themes for Alabama Messaging
Suggested Talking Points:
Facilitation Guide
Step 1: Set the Tone
Step 2: Begin Discussion (sample questions)
Step 3: Handling Tough Questions
Educators
Key Themes for Educators Messaging
Human Rights Education
Students must understand that the Eighth Amendment and human rights standards exist to protect human dignity—even inside prisons. The violations documented in Alabama prisons are lessons in what happens when systems fail.
Civic Responsibility
Education is not neutral. Teachers and professors help students connect the dots between public policy, government accountability, and lived experience. Understanding the prison crisis is part of preparing students to be informed, responsible citizens.
Critical Media Literacy
The film is built on footage captured directly by incarcerated men. For students, this is an opportunity to interrogate how truth is documented, whose voices are centered, and how narratives can disrupt official accounts.
Empathy and Engagement
Exposure to these realities challenges students to think about justice not just as punishment but as restoration. Classrooms are spaces to cultivate empathy alongside critical thinking.
Suggested Talking Points:
Facilitation Guide
Step 1: Set the Tone
Introduce the film as both a documentary and a primary source. Acknowledge that the material is graphic and emotionally difficult, and set clear ground rules for respectful discussion. Invite students to approach the content critically, but also with empathy.
Step 2: Begin Discussion (sample questions for classroom settings)
Step 3: Handling Tough Questions
If challenged with “they broke the law”:
If students question why this matters to them:
If asked “what can I do?” → Emphasize learning and sharing:
What Comes Next
Public campaign actions will begin on Friday, October 10. Until then, we’re asking everyone simply to share their contact information at our impact campaign website, which will go live that day but already has a contact form to stay connected. The more people who sign on now, the stronger our launch will be once we share materials for you to amplify and actions for you to take.
When the site goes live, you’ll see clear ways to get involved. We’ll be asking Alabamians to press state leaders to fire abusive officers, protect whistleblowers like Robert Earl Council and Melvin Ray, call out corporations with Alabama ties or presence who are profiting from prison labor, and demand real oversight reform. Nationally, we’ll be inviting people to push for federal accountability, call out corporations operating and profiting off prison labor in other states, and stand in solidarity with families of the incarcerated.
The goal is simple: come out of the gate with a strong, unified show of support so that when the public campaign begins, state and national leaders cannot ignore the call for change.
Faith Leaders
Key Themes for Faith Leader Messaging
Human Dignity
Every person is created with inherent worth. The treatment exposed in Alabama and other US prisons is a violation of that basic truth. Faith communities must remind the public that justice without dignity is not justice at all.
Moral Responsibility
Serving time is not a license for abuse. When institutions fail to protect life, faith leaders are called to bear witness and demand accountability. Silence makes us complicit.
Community Stewardship
Prisons are not abstract—they are filled with fathers, sons, mothers, and daughters from our communities. Congregations share in the pain when families are torn apart. To protect our communities, we must protect the people inside.
Prophetic Witness
Scripture and tradition call on faith leaders to speak truth to power. The Alabama Solution offers evidence that cannot be ignored. Faith leaders have the moral authority to demand that public officials act with transparency, compassion, and justice.
Suggested Talking Points:
Facilitation Guide
Step 1: Set the Tone
Open with gratitude for attendees’ presence and ground the space in shared values of dignity, compassion, and justice. Remind participants that the stories in the film are difficult but reveal truths that demand a moral response. Frame the discussion as an act of bearing witness.
Step 2: Begin Discussion (sample questions for clergy audiences)
Step 3: Handling Tough Questions
If challenged on “criminals deserving punishment”: Reframe around moral duty.
If questions focus on the church’s role: Center prophetic witness.
If asked “what can I do?” → Point directly to campaign Calls to Action below, and emphasize collective power.
What Comes Next
Public campaign actions will begin on Friday, October 10. Until then, we’re asking everyone simply to share their contact information at our impact campaign website, which will go live that day but already has a contact form to stay connected. The more people who sign on now, the stronger our launch will be once we share materials for you to amplify and actions for you to take.
When the site goes live, you’ll see clear ways to get involved. We’ll be asking Alabamians to press state leaders to fire abusive officers, protect whistleblowers like Robert Earl Council and Melvin Ray, call out corporations with Alabama ties or presence who are profiting from prison labor, and demand real oversight reform. Nationally, we’ll be inviting people to push for federal accountability, call out corporations operating and profiting off prison labor in other states, and stand in solidarity with families of the incarcerated.
The goal is simple: come out of the gate with a strong, unified show of support so that when the public campaign begins, state and national leaders cannot ignore the call for change.
Parents
Key Themes for Parents Messaging
Family Protection
Prisons are not isolated—they are part of our communities. The men in these stories are sons, brothers, fathers. Every death or act of abuse reverberates through families, leaving children and parents behind.
Accountability for the Next Generation
Parents work to teach their children fairness, honesty, and responsibility. When state institutions hide abuse and neglect, they undermine those same lessons. Families have a right to expect better.
Community Safety
Real safety comes from prevention, fairness, and rehabilitation—not secrecy or violence. Parents have the strongest stake in building a society where their children are safe inside and outside the walls.
Moral Example
Children watch how adults respond to injustice. Speaking out against abuse is part of teaching them to live with integrity, compassion, and courage.
Suggested Talking Points:
Facilitation Guide
Step 1: Set the Tone
Acknowledge the emotional weight of the film. Frame the conversation as parents and caregivers trying to ensure a safer, more honest future for their children.
Step 2: Begin Discussion (sample questions for family-oriented groups)
Step 3: Handling Tough Questions
If challenged with “prison is supposed to be hard”:
If asked why parents should care:
If asked “what can I do?” → Emphasize family voice:
What Comes Next
Public campaign actions will begin on Friday, October 10. Until then, we’re asking everyone simply to share their contact information at our impact campaign website, which will go live that day but already has a contact form to stay connected. The more people who sign on now, the stronger our launch will be once we share materials for you to amplify and actions for you to take.
When the site goes live, you’ll see clear ways to get involved. We’ll be asking Alabamians to press state leaders to fire abusive officers, protect whistleblowers like Robert Earl Council and Melvin Ray, call out corporations with Alabama ties or presence who are profiting from prison labor, and demand real oversight reform. Nationally, we’ll be inviting people to push for federal accountability, call out corporations operating and profiting off prison labor in other states, and stand in solidarity with families of the incarcerated.
The goal is simple: come out of the gate with a strong, unified show of support so that when the public campaign begins, state and national leaders cannot ignore the call for change.
Sports Coaches
Key Themes for Sports Messaging
Team and Brotherhood
Prison abuse tears apart families and communities—the same families who fill stadiums and put their trust in sports. The young men on our teams are sons, brothers, and fathers. Their lives are worth protecting on and off the field.
Discipline vs. Abuse
Coaches know the difference between tough discipline that builds strength and abuse that breaks spirit. The film makes clear that Alabama’s prisons cross that line every day.
Role Models and Leadership
Players look to coaches for guidance on what integrity, respect, and accountability look like. Speaking up about injustice is part of showing the next generation what leadership means.
Community Pride
Sports bind communities together. If we want to cheer for our teams with pride, we also need to make sure the communities those athletes come from are safe, fair, and whole.
Suggested Talking Points:
Facilitation Guide
Step 1: Set the Tone
Frame the conversation around teamwork and integrity. Remind athletes and community members that what happens in our prisons is not about “others”—it’s about our teammates, classmates, and neighbors.
Step 2: Begin Discussion (sample questions for sports settings)
Step 3: Handling Tough Questions
If challenged with “they broke the law”:
If asked why coaches should care:
If asked “what can we do?” → Emphasize community leadership:
Closing Remarks
This film is difficult to watch because it shows what Alabama’s leaders want to keep hidden. The stories of Sandy Davis, Robert Earl Council, and Melvin Ray remind us that change is possible only when communities take action.
End every screening by pointing audiences directly to the No More Alabama campaign QR code, displayed at the end of the film file after the credits.
Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.
This is not the way.
Try clicking the ··· in the right corner or using a keyboard shortcut (
CtrlP
) instead.