Skip to content
Modern philosophy is stuck: Dewart argues that despite attempts to understand the human mind, philosophy hasn’t made significant progress. He sees the debate between “cognitivism” and traditional approaches as evidence of this stagnation.The problem lies in history: Dewart believes that modern philosophers haven’t adequately learned from the history of philosophy, particularly the failures of late scholasticism. He argues that Descartes and his successors unknowingly adopted flawed assumptions that led to the downfall of earlier philosophical thought.We’ve forgotten the lessons of the past: The author points to the “existential skepticism” of David Hume as a symptom of these inherited flaws. He argues that while philosophers rejected Hume’s skepticism, they failed to address the underlying assumptions that made such skepticism possible in the first place.Historical awareness is key: Dewart emphasizes the importance of understanding the historical development of philosophical ideas. He believes that by studying the past, philosophers can identify and correct the mistakes that have hindered progress.A new approach is needed: The book proposes a re-examination of fundamental concepts like cognition, reality, and causality. Dewart suggests that these concepts need to be redefined based on a more accurate understanding of the human mind and its relationship to the world.Part I: The Challenge of Hume and Philosophy’s Failure to Meet It: This section introduces the central problem of philosophical stagnation and outlines the historical context.Part II: The Causes of the Stagnation of Modern Philosophy: the Historical Evidence: This part delves into the historical roots of the problem, tracing it back to Greek philosophy and its influence on later thinkers.Part III: The Initial Assumptions of Post Humean Philosophy: Here, Dewart critiques traditional assumptions about causality, perception, and reality, proposing alternative ways of understanding these concepts.Part IV: Living Consciously: Speech, Thought, and Understanding: This section explores the nature of consciousness, language, and thought, suggesting a new framework for understanding the human mind.
Introduction
Summary of “Hume’s Challenge and the Renewal of Modern Philosophy”:
This book argues that modern philosophy, particularly the study of the human mind, has stagnated since the time of René Descartes and David Hume. The author, Leslie Dewart, believes that this stagnation results from overlooking crucial philosophical developments in the late Middle Ages.
Here’s a breakdown of the book’s core arguments:
The book is structured as follows:
In essence, Dewart calls for a “renewal” of modern philosophy, urging philosophers to learn from the past, challenge existing assumptions, and develop new approaches to understanding the human mind and its place in the world.
Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.
This is not the way.
Try clicking the ··· in the right corner or using a keyboard shortcut (
CtrlP
) instead.